I get what you mean, but my intention was just so that we can get a better standards between reviewers. That alone will already make it easier for readers/viewers as there will at least be a bit more objective consistency between reviewers..
But yeah, I think we need to come up with a review system. We can come up with a catchy name maybe a logo... And the when reviewers score and compare using our system, they can go ahead and attach that logo to their review. I know this thread started off about the trust of reviewers, but I feel that consistency and having a standard would perhaps make it all the more easier to build that trust
It was something Warren and I discussed some time ago when I was a Moderator. He actually had the bare bones of a reviewing format fleshed out. Add that to a scoring format - including giving people a template - and yes it could work quite well. Whether other people were actually interested in using it - would be another matter.