What is your favorite pink floyd album?

Dec 9, 2005 at 4:20 PM Thread Starter Post #1 of 35

aaroncort

Banned
Joined
Jun 3, 2004
Posts
1,147
Likes
11
I'm going to give pink floyd another chance. I liked them in junior high but really started to dislike them in highschool. I believe now i'm a more critical listener and really want to like them. I want to know which album you like the best excluding the major 2, dark side of the moon and the wall. I've heard Animals is quite good and i'm going to pick it up most likely when I go to best buy later today. I have money for 2 more albums. Which ones do you think I should get? Thanks for your input, aaron.
 
Dec 9, 2005 at 4:34 PM Post #2 of 35
Well, add 'Meddle' to your list. There is absolutely no doubt in the minds of most Pink Floyd fans that this is one of the pinacles of their work. 'Echoes' is just, simply put, an incredible song, and the rest of the music is stellar as well. This shows a more moody and chilled out kind of aspect to Pink Floyd's sound, and it should not be missed. After that, I would suggest picking up 'Obscured By Clouds' which would, to me, sound all like early Beatles songs if the tempo was sped up and the lyrics changed. However, there's enough experimentation in the album to strike a good balance between accessibility and coolness. This is actually a soundtrack to the film 'La Valee', but it is still one of Pink Floyd's best efforts. The singing and drumming are praticularly strong in this album. The tunes on this album are incredibly catchy.

I chose these based on both beginner's experiences I have had and my favorite albums. When I introduced a friend to Pink Floyd a year and a half ago, I put him straight to 'Piper at the Gates of Dawn', and went up the list until he heard something he truly loved. He liked Piper a lot, but the band is much different now than it was back then with the absense of Syd Barrett. He heard 'A Saucerful of Secrets' and thought it was a little too amateur-ish for him. Then he went up the list until he hit Meddle and Obscured By Clouds, in order, and loved them both. He went up to Dark Side of the Moon and loved that too, and Animals, and then hated The Wall and everything past that. He still hates the Roger Waters dominance material, but loves everything else now
biggrin.gif


If you buy these two albums I suggested above, I'd suggest these purchases in this order:

-Piper at the Gates of Dawn
-Animals
-Atom Heart Mother
-A Saucerful of Secrets

Hope this helps.
 
Dec 9, 2005 at 5:08 PM Post #3 of 35
thanks for the input, I'll pick up meddle today an most likely pick up obcured by clouds later. I'll see how I take to them before I spend anymore money. Thanks a bunch for you recomendations. If anybody elso wants to chime in too be my guest, Aaron.
 
Dec 9, 2005 at 5:11 PM Post #4 of 35
I really like Relics. It probably wouldn't be a popular pick since it's rather quirky, but it definitely wins some points for origionality.
 
Dec 9, 2005 at 5:25 PM Post #6 of 35
Wish you were here. =)
Meddle is good too
 
Dec 9, 2005 at 5:43 PM Post #8 of 35
Quote:

Originally Posted by aaroncort
I'm going to give pink floyd another chance. I liked them in junior high but really started to dislike them in highschool. I believe now i'm a more critical listener and really want to like them.


If it doesn't happen it doesn't mean you've not become a more critical listener. Despite being immortal much of Pink Floyd sounds really dated. If I played Floyd now for my friends who grew up with it, they'd not be careful with that axe.

Hey Aman I just discovered a site you might like.

http://www.progreviews.com/
 
Dec 9, 2005 at 5:43 PM Post #9 of 35
Meddle is great.

Definitely some interesting recs, outside of the usual Floyd path.

Dark Side of the Moon is the obvious starter album for most, but its a bit overrated and you have likely already heard the songs over and over already.

Wish You Were Here, Animals, DOSTM and The Wall (astonishingly not mentioned yet) are the 'obvious' choices.

What type of music do you like? Know that will make it easier to reccommend which path to take. Especially since floyd can be VERY different stuff, but uniformly excellent as well.
 
Dec 9, 2005 at 5:44 PM Post #10 of 35
Wish You Were Here.
Quite possibly the best album of all time (of course-IMO)
That album is like gettting on a spaceship and flying through the solar system while drinking some fine red wine and watching the planets go by.
LOL.
I cant beleive I just wrote that.
Lotta acid in my earlier days
biggrin.gif
 
Dec 9, 2005 at 5:48 PM Post #11 of 35
Quote:

Originally Posted by eyeteeth
If it doesn't happen it doesn't mean you've not become a more critical listener. Despite being immortal much of Pink Floyd sounds really dated. If I played Floyd now for my friends who grew up with it, they'd not be careful with that axe.

Hey Aman I just discovered a site you might like.

http://www.progreviews.com/



Thanks for the linky eyeteeth!
smily_headphones1.gif
I have been frequenting a website called www.progarchives.com but the reviews are much less stellar than this site you just informed me about.

Cheers, sir!
-Andrew

(By the way, nice Pink Floyd pun there
biggrin.gif
)
 
Dec 9, 2005 at 5:50 PM Post #12 of 35
A toss up between Wish You Were Here and Animals. Animals tends to be overlooked by casual fans, but it's a stellar album. Dark Side is still my favorite album, by anyone.
 
Dec 9, 2005 at 6:01 PM Post #13 of 35
Quote:

Originally Posted by Coltrane
Meddle is great.

Definitely some interesting recs, outside of the usual Floyd path.

Dark Side of the Moon is the obvious starter album for most, but its a bit overrated and you have likely already heard the songs over and over already.

Wish You Were Here, Animals, DOSTM and The Wall (astonishingly not mentioned yet) are the 'obvious' choices.

What type of music do you like? Know that will make it easier to reccommend which path to take. Especially since floyd can be VERY different stuff, but uniformly excellent as well.



I appreciate your concern, although this always sounds like a blowhard statment whenever I hear it i'm going to say it anyway. I feel that I can get into almost any type of music if alot of care went into it's construction. some of my favorite albums however are, Amon Tobins albums-Permutation and Bricolage, Flaming lips-the soft bulletin, Neutral Milk Hotel-In an airplain over the seas, radioheads-kid A and OK computer, Arcade Fire's-Funeral, Bonnie "Prince" Billie's_I see a Darkness, Bach's Goldberg variation, Bach's six suits for solo violincello, the microphones albums-the glow part two and It was hot we stayed in the water, ...And you shall know us by the trail of dead-source tags and codes, and bjork's-homogenic. Hope that helps at all.
 
Dec 9, 2005 at 6:08 PM Post #14 of 35
If you dig the Lips, Radiohead and Neutral Milk Hotel you will eventually like all Pink Floyd. Have fun!

But to give you some idea, early Pink Floyd is much more quirky, like NMH. So Saucerful of Secrets, Piperat the Gates of Dawn, and even Obscured by Clouds will be more like them.

Meddle is more long soundscape stuff, in fact the majority of the album is one song. Wish You Were Here is mainly 'one' song that brackets the middle of the album. Soundscapey type stuff there too. Dark Side, Wall, and Animals are a bit more 'song' based. Definitely where the big influences of Flaming Lips and Radiohead are.

Again though, I think you will like all of it. Just go in with REALLY open ears and all will be well.
 
Dec 9, 2005 at 6:34 PM Post #15 of 35
Quote:

Originally Posted by Bleeding Spark
A toss up between Wish You Were Here and Animals. Animals tends to be overlooked by casual fans, but it's a stellar album. Dark Side is still my favorite album, by anyone.


Obviously we have similar musical taste
smily_headphones1.gif
, especially considering your username. I think that the post-syd albums are mostly dismissable as tripe, except for animals and wish you were here...
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top