maxx76
New Head-Fier
- Joined
- Feb 7, 2003
- Posts
- 6
- Likes
- 0
Hi there-it's actually my first post here in head fi and im hoping to get some information from fellow head fi'ers regarding maintenance and care of a tubed cdp unit. Ive had the chance to own a Shanling SCD-T200C used with a 2 chanel system setup last December and unfortunately within less than a month
the player had problems reading out cd's and sacd; the blue laser light was obviously no longer reading the cd's full data as the audio technician observed. A month after the unit was brought back fully repaired and making things worse after another month's use the unit was only giving sound to the left channel of the speaker-even with a headphone setup. Hence we had to bring it back and have not received any complete explanation as to what happened with the unit. I was given a couple of demo cdp's-all solid state ranging from MF to Marantz to Rotel and none of them gave me the same problem I had with the Shanling-despite the fact that there were times that they could not read cd's with minor scratches on the surface but it never gave out the way my Shanling did. Are tubed cdp's much more sensitive to the quality of the disc media fed on them and are they much more prone to heat/dust/humidity factor compared with solid state? I did recall Shanling was basically a open top loader(i.e. Rega) not the drawer type units we often see in solid state and to some extent tubed units(B.A.T. and Audio Aero cdp's). Im once again a proud owner of another tubed unit; which this time is a drawer type though. Ive already bought a separate and dedicated power strip for it and positioned it at least a foot away from the wall. Ive been scanning audio mags for all other necessary room treatments and accessories i may need to have as well to mantain this unit to it's expected 3-5 year lifespan. But i'd appreciate if i could get any insights and opinions from you guys; who's at least had much more experience in owning audio systems and at least get a analysis from you as to why the previous unit just broke down. I do like sound quality of tubed player's but really if it's gonna be hard to mantain them for the years to come i would not hesitate to replace it with a robust solid state player considering that I have a 6-day work week and could not possibly have all the time to keep checking it and travelling back/forth to the service center. Sorry for the long post, but i do hope to get subjective analysis from you guys and specially those who have been mantaining a tubed system as to what a new owner like me could expect. Thanks.
the player had problems reading out cd's and sacd; the blue laser light was obviously no longer reading the cd's full data as the audio technician observed. A month after the unit was brought back fully repaired and making things worse after another month's use the unit was only giving sound to the left channel of the speaker-even with a headphone setup. Hence we had to bring it back and have not received any complete explanation as to what happened with the unit. I was given a couple of demo cdp's-all solid state ranging from MF to Marantz to Rotel and none of them gave me the same problem I had with the Shanling-despite the fact that there were times that they could not read cd's with minor scratches on the surface but it never gave out the way my Shanling did. Are tubed cdp's much more sensitive to the quality of the disc media fed on them and are they much more prone to heat/dust/humidity factor compared with solid state? I did recall Shanling was basically a open top loader(i.e. Rega) not the drawer type units we often see in solid state and to some extent tubed units(B.A.T. and Audio Aero cdp's). Im once again a proud owner of another tubed unit; which this time is a drawer type though. Ive already bought a separate and dedicated power strip for it and positioned it at least a foot away from the wall. Ive been scanning audio mags for all other necessary room treatments and accessories i may need to have as well to mantain this unit to it's expected 3-5 year lifespan. But i'd appreciate if i could get any insights and opinions from you guys; who's at least had much more experience in owning audio systems and at least get a analysis from you as to why the previous unit just broke down. I do like sound quality of tubed player's but really if it's gonna be hard to mantain them for the years to come i would not hesitate to replace it with a robust solid state player considering that I have a 6-day work week and could not possibly have all the time to keep checking it and travelling back/forth to the service center. Sorry for the long post, but i do hope to get subjective analysis from you guys and specially those who have been mantaining a tubed system as to what a new owner like me could expect. Thanks.