TOTALDAC DAC
May 18, 2016 at 8:14 AM Post #511 of 581

astrostar59

Banned
Member of the Trade: Aries Cerat Espana, Auriculares High-End
AKA Headstage, headphoneweekend
Joined
Aug 23, 2012
Posts
2,843
Likes
852
Location
Somewhere v hot
  I went through many DAC's, and once I got a Totaldac, I was done listening to other pieces. Very right sounding stuff from Vincent, and I never get tired of listening to it.

Yes, I can imagine that is where TotalDAC sits. Trouble is I can't get to try one without paying the 100% cost first (10 day return deal).
 
My thoughts are my Audio Note DAC 4 which is tweaked up may well be close to the Audio Note DAC 5 Special. How far ahead the TotalDAC will be I have no idea.
 
A lot of the impact and sound improvements from users here sen to be folk leaving the DS camp and entering the R-2R camp. I am interested in hose who have heard other top R-2R DACs alongside the TotalDAC.
 
My curiosity over the MSB may be the wrong road for me on reflection. I don't need more detail as that could start to sound unreal and digital. I note that MSB has taken a rather risky strategy recently and dropped the Platinum IV unit which was around 10K. So they now go from the Analogue DAC at 8K to the 24K Signature DAC. Seems like they have lost a busy middle budget area there IMO.
 
On TotalDAC, has anyone heard the D1 Single to the D1 Dual, or D1 Six, and how is the more costly DACs sound different? I can never afford a Six, maybe not a Dual either unless used, but the Single is attractively priced. But not if it is well below the Dual for example.
 
Any insight would be very useful to me.
 
May 18, 2016 at 10:37 AM Post #512 of 581

cladane

500+ Head-Fier
Joined
Jan 19, 2013
Posts
631
Likes
102
Location
France
Hello Astrostar59,
 
For the trial, is the check cashed ?? I thought Vincent kept the check until the buyer decided to buy or return the DAC.
 
Having the D1 Integral-Headphone (which is a D1 Single with the server and headphone amp), I can say that sound is detailed, transparent, not at all digital (no brilliance on highs).
Very fast DAC, zero noise and digital volume on 69 bits making it a very good preamp (for amps driving sensitive headphones).
 
Owning an SE amp, the D1-Dual is not mandatory moreover listening to headphones.
 
If you go balanced with headphones or mono blocks for speakers, the D1 Dual can be an improvement (particularly for speakers) but I listened to it (with headphones) and difference isn't huge.
 
With TotalDAC be aware that you can upscale the device at any time.
 
May 20, 2016 at 3:08 PM Post #513 of 581

astrostar59

Banned
Member of the Trade: Aries Cerat Espana, Auriculares High-End
AKA Headstage, headphoneweekend
Joined
Aug 23, 2012
Posts
2,843
Likes
852
Location
Somewhere v hot
Couple of questions.
 
1. How does the D1 Single compare to the Dual or Six in sound quality? Is it a big jump or is it more flavours and subtle?
 
2. Has anyone migrated from an MSB Platinum IV and is so how did the MSB compare to the TotalDAC? Both are R-2R but MSB do up sampling and filtering I believe?
 
3. Has anyone compared the TotalDAC to an Audio Note DAC 4 or a Lampizator Big 7 or Golden Gate?
 
I like warm, fluid and smooth with enough detail (not detail mad).
 
I wonder how much it would cost to have a D1 single upgraded to a Dual after purchase?
 
Any insight would be great.
 
May 20, 2016 at 3:19 PM Post #514 of 581

paul79

100+ Head-Fier
Joined
Apr 29, 2012
Posts
103
Likes
45
As you move up the Totaldac line, you simply get more good and nothing bad.
More dynamics, deeper, wider, more refinement in detail, imaging, lower noise floor..... They are all very good, but as you move up, you get more. It is tough to explain, but the D1 Dual is the best bang for buck I think if you want only a DAC from Vincent. The D1 Six with Server option is a great option for an all in one chassis very high end solution.
 
I love these products so much, I now have the Twelve, and it has been most incredible.
 
Vincent typically upgrades for the cost difference in the DAC's only, so pretty simple math.
 
I know of one person who compared the D1 Dual to the Diamond MSB and said that in testing with a group, more people preferred the Totaldac.
 
May 21, 2016 at 6:40 PM Post #515 of 581

cat6man

500+ Head-Fier
Joined
Jul 9, 2008
Posts
821
Likes
62
when i was dac hunting, the msb diamond (with femto clock) and the D1-dual were head and shoulders above any of the others i listened to in my house (ayre, aeshetix, wadia, viola, bricasti).
since i did not have them under equivalent testing conditions, i cannot give a comparison between the msb and the D1-dual but both were magical.
 
i plan to upgrade the d1-dual to d1-six in the coming year.
 
May 21, 2016 at 7:39 PM Post #516 of 581

a1uc

500+ Head-Fier
Joined
May 1, 2012
Posts
537
Likes
56
As you move up the Totaldac line, you simply get more good and nothing bad.
More dynamics, deeper, wider, more refinement in detail, imaging, lower noise floor..... They are all very good, but as you move up, you get more. It is tough to explain, but the D1 Dual is the best bang for buck I think if you want only a DAC from Vincent. The D1 Six with Server option is a great option for an all in one chassis very high end solution.

I love these products so much, I now have the Twelve, and it has been most incredible.

Vincent typically upgrades for the cost difference in the DAC's only, so pretty simple math.

I know of one person who compared the D1 Dual to the Diamond MSB and said that in testing with a group, more people preferred the Totaldac.
The diffrence for me from the dual to the monoblocks was not anywhere as huge as from the monoblocks to the twelve , I would like to hear the six also curious
 
May 28, 2016 at 8:34 PM Post #517 of 581

paradoxper

Headphoneus Supremus
Joined
Mar 10, 2012
Posts
9,329
Likes
4,553
  Hi Guys
Where does the TotalDAC Dual sit in the DAC heavyweights?
 
I am chewing over a new TotalDAC dual or a used MSB Platinum IV or used C1 CH Precision (though the later is new so hard to find used). I did consider a used Audio Note DAC 5 Special but that DAC design is now very long in the tooth and the unit I saw was 8 years old.
 
I have read as many bad reviews of the MSB as good ones. The negatives are always 'too cold' 'clinical' or 'over detailed', 'not realistic'. The positive reviews seem to wow over MSB but maybe that is the DS to R-2R change over? I am not sure MSB are non oversampling actually. They are a ladder DAC but seem to oversample / upsample everything and have a filter which I don't like.
 
So any of you TotalDAC owners heard the MSB stack or the C1. I am thinking the Lampi Big 7 would be a real close run thing, but for some reason I don't like the build quality of those products.
 
Any insight would be great. I may audition a C1 in a few weeks to see where my Audio Not DAC 4 sits, maybe it is a close call and not worth the move?

In the same boat. Also interested in comparisons with the Kalliope. Seems an in-home trial is the only way to go, which seems rather difficult.
 
Jul 7, 2016 at 11:34 AM Post #518 of 581

paradoxper

Headphoneus Supremus
Joined
Mar 10, 2012
Posts
9,329
Likes
4,553
This may be a long shot, oh well. Any TotalDAC comparison with the likes of EMM, Playback Designs, MSB, or CH? I've arranged some demo units, however, this won't be in motion until my T2 is completed. So any tidbits would be appreciated to help streamline my process.
 
Jul 9, 2016 at 12:50 PM Post #519 of 581

cat6man

500+ Head-Fier
Joined
Jul 9, 2008
Posts
821
Likes
62
i have a sonore microRendu feeding the D1-dual via usb and it is astonishing, even before i've put a decent power supply on it.
i wouldn't be surprised if this matched or exceeded the totalDAC server, but then i've never heard the totaldac server.
i hope someone out there with the totaldac server can get their hands on a microRendu and give us a comparison
 
Jul 9, 2016 at 6:01 PM Post #521 of 581

astrostar59

Banned
Member of the Trade: Aries Cerat Espana, Auriculares High-End
AKA Headstage, headphoneweekend
Joined
Aug 23, 2012
Posts
2,843
Likes
852
Location
Somewhere v hot
  This may be a long shot, oh well. Any TotalDAC comparison with the likes of EMM, Playback Designs, MSB, or CH? I've arranged some demo units, however, this won't be in motion until my T2 is completed. So any tidbits would be appreciated to help streamline my process.

From talking to folk who have a TotalDAC I would hazard it sounds warmer and possibly more natural than the EMM and MSB. There seems to be 2 camps of high end DACs and the detailed camp seems to contain MSB, EMMlabs with Audio Note and some of the Lampizator units at the other warmer camp. The TotalDAC is probably in the middle. IMO the challenge is to find the type of DAC that sounds right to you. Hearing in your system is a perfect way to do that.
 
I am committed to the Audio Note DAC 5 now, but if I moved again I would look at the TotalDAC for sure. If more budget, then the C1.
 
Jul 9, 2016 at 6:16 PM Post #522 of 581

paradoxper

Headphoneus Supremus
Joined
Mar 10, 2012
Posts
9,329
Likes
4,553
  From talking to folk who have a TotalDAC I would hazard it sounds warmer and possibly more natural than the EMM and MSB. There seems to be 2 camps of high end DACs and the detailed camp seems to contain MSB, EMMlabs with Audio Note and some of the Lampizator units at the other warmer camp. The TotalDAC is probably in the middle. IMO the challenge is to find the type of DAC that sounds right to you. Hearing in your system is a perfect way to do that.
 
I am committed to the Audio Note DAC 5 now, but if I moved again I would look at the TotalDAC for sure. If more budget, then the C1.

That doesn't quite help and there's a lot of generalizing there. I am interested in context tied to the chain.
 
 I knew it may be a long shot, but I'm looking for anyone who may have stronger reference points.
 
The TotalDAC options are overwhelming and gives me the feeling to skip it. Want to make sure I avoid regrets.
 
Jul 9, 2016 at 7:41 PM Post #523 of 581

paul79

100+ Head-Fier
Joined
Apr 29, 2012
Posts
103
Likes
45
I wouldn't be put off by the multiple Totaldac offerings. He provides different options for different budgets and people's needs. IME, just getting your foot in the door at your budget with a Totaldac, and you are in some seriously fine company. They are just right sounding no matter which one you can get. They are different from other DAC's in that they are like choosing a turntable that fits your budget, and I mean this in the best way. They are special. They are Analog in digital form.
 
As you move up the line, you get more of what the entry level Totaldac's offer. More separation, lower noise floor, more dynamics, more focus, more transparency, more more more.  :) Even the entry level are completely musically satisfying.
 
His best bang for buck is the all in one D1 six DAC with Server. IMO, there is no finer all in one DAC/Server than this. Not cheap, but one listen and there is no remorse. NONE.
 
Jul 9, 2016 at 8:01 PM Post #524 of 581

paradoxper

Headphoneus Supremus
Joined
Mar 10, 2012
Posts
9,329
Likes
4,553
  I wouldn't be put off by the multiple Totaldac offerings. He provides different options for different budgets and people's needs. IME, just getting your foot in the door at your budget with a Totaldac, and you are in some seriously fine company. They are just right sounding no matter which one you can get. They are different from other DAC's in that they are like choosing a turntable that fits your budget, and I mean this in the best way. They are special. They are Analog in digital form.
 
As you move up the line, you get more of what the entry level Totaldac's offer. More separation, lower noise floor, more dynamics, more focus, more transparency, more more more.  :) Even the entry level are completely musically satisfying.
 
His best bang for buck is the all in one D1 six DAC with Server. IMO, there is no finer all in one DAC/Server than this. Not cheap, but one listen and there is no remorse. NONE.

They seem like a great value for what you're getting in the entry. To be fair, everyone seems rather satisfied with the offerings. Like, the Analog > Diamond, for example. I am certainly looking for a comparative viewpoint.
 
Thanks for your input, though.
 
Jul 10, 2016 at 6:44 AM Post #525 of 581

astrostar59

Banned
Member of the Trade: Aries Cerat Espana, Auriculares High-End
AKA Headstage, headphoneweekend
Joined
Aug 23, 2012
Posts
2,843
Likes
852
Location
Somewhere v hot
  They seem like a great value for what you're getting in the entry. To be fair, everyone seems rather satisfied with the offerings. Like, the Analog > Diamond, for example. I am certainly looking for a comparative viewpoint.
 
Thanks for your input, though.

I can't find ANYONE who has not liked the TotalDAC which ever model, reviewers or owners. Many owners do upgrade in the TotalDAC family, but that is a good thing not bad IMO. I have stayed in the Audio Note family because it gives me everything I want. TotalDAC would be my second choice for sure. The Dual is £7.5K as has been compared to many DACs at 20K. 
 
Paradoxper, you could try PM'ing Preproman as he had a TotalDAC dual on a 2 week home demo and also owned the EMMlabs DAC 2X for a long time.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top