Tanchjim in ear monitors Impressions Thread
post-14977560
Post #316 of 812

warriorpoet

500+ Head-Fier
Joined
Mar 9, 2019
Messages
838
Reaction score
863
Location
United States
Joined
Mar 9, 2019
Location
United States
Posts
838
Likes
863
Well...looks like I'll be selling them. Good texturing, but hard kicks from the too eager bass region proved to be very intrusive. Not even the leakiest eartips helped to hammer that intrusive sub-bass flat.

Guess it's a lucky thing I didn't try the Kanas Pros as well, as it was touted as having even moar of that. Imagine the disappointment.

In a way it's like eating ketchup, chillie sauce and condiments instead of the actual food on the plate itself.

I'll have to move on and continue searching. Flat with out of head soundstage. No extra treble, no mega bass extra booost, no enhanced mids. Just no extras, no reduction, no nonsense. Just there.
When you find them, let me know! I'm after the same.
 
     Share This Post       
post-14977732
Post #318 of 812

surfgeorge

Member of the Trade: 3D Printed Accessory Designer
Joined
Feb 26, 2018
Messages
1,437
Reaction score
1,217
Location
Austria
Joined
Feb 26, 2018
Location
Austria
Posts
1,437
Likes
1,217
Well...looks like I'll be selling them. Good texturing, but hard kicks from the too eager bass region proved to be very intrusive. Not even the leakiest eartips helped to hammer that intrusive sub-bass flat.

Guess it's a lucky thing I didn't try the Kanas Pros as well, as it was touted as having even moar of that. Imagine the disappointment.

In a way it's like eating ketchup, chillie sauce and condiments instead of the actual food on the plate itself.

I'll have to move on and continue searching. Flat with out of head soundstage. No extra treble, no mega bass extra booost, no enhanced mids. Just no extras, no reduction, no nonsense. Just there.
Did you consider the Sony EX800ST?
Famous for controlled and fast bass, huge soundstage (with very bad isolation, basically semi-open)
Available on Amazon Japan.

Crinacle's measurement
Sony EX800ST Stock.jpg
 
     Share This Post       
post-14977735
Post #319 of 812

416805

New Head-Fier
Joined
Jan 18, 2015
Messages
0
Reaction score
2
Joined
Jan 18, 2015
Posts
0
Likes
2
isn't the ex800 and ex1k have treble "problem" some people can't stand the high treble that might be a problem.

but i would rec ex800/ex1k tbh. both have great rep.
 
     Share This Post       
post-14977956
Post #320 of 812

Nabillion_786

500+ Head-Fier
Joined
Jun 17, 2018
Messages
705
Reaction score
250
Location
Chichester
Joined
Jun 17, 2018
Location
Chichester
Posts
705
Likes
250
Guys, I was not comparing KPE to Oxygen! Didn`t say a word about KPE and I`m free to express my opinion about something.

I was talking about price of Oxygen with upgrade cable. For me that "upgrade" cable should have been in the package from the beginning!
I understand when someone wants to "tweak" sound little with cable, do it at free will and money, but at such price I would not want to spend more money for "upgrade" cable
to get same "You have to get that cable to get full potential we are hearing" impression as others.
Then personally I think Oxygen nozzle is short (I`m not only one), which can cause issues with finding right tips.
Sorry, but those things considered I`m still at attitude that Oxygen is not worth that 330$.
Others opinion may vary and I respect that.

For what it`s worth, I do think SQ-wise Oxygen is probably somewhat better than KPE but I personally don`t think the price difference is justified.
Value wise I definitely agree with you that kanas pro gives more for what its worth but I felt vocals good have been slightly more forward with fuller male vocals. Vocals are a huge deal for me, they have to sound rich, clear and not even slightly recessed. From my experience with the many many chifi iems I have tried, none of these iems ticked all 3 boxes soo I heightened my budget and feel like finally the oxygen is what I was after. Obviously it's not perfect though but I am happy with it. The main flaw I would personally give to the oxygen is that it can sound a bit too gentle and smooth which make it sound a bit boring at times depending on my mood. Other nitpicks like even more clarity is probably not fair or realistic as this and the kanas pro are the clearest sounding single DD iems I have heard upto that price range. Even the ex800 sounded less clear to me for my ears which resulted in me returning them back.

Also, I was very scared about the fit of the oxygen's before purchase but must say they fit more comfortable and better for me then the kpe.
 
Last edited:
     Share This Post       
  • Like
Reactions: CoiL
post-14978011
Post #321 of 812

CoiL

Member of the Trade: Wood Audio Accessories & Modifications
Joined
Jan 23, 2013
Messages
6,319
Reaction score
3,150
Location
Estonia
Joined
Jan 23, 2013
Location
Estonia
Posts
6,319
Likes
3,150
how is it defensive when u didn't even provide a simple alternatives.
My post was not about providing alternatives. It was about Oxygen pricing regarding its "faults" - need for "upgrade" cable (#1 product package value issue) and short nozzle (#2 design issue).
#1 - for price near 300$ customer wouldn`t want to spend any additional cost for another basic part of quality IEM package. 60$ extra isn`t cheap for something that should be already in the bundle to get the best out of product it is able to provide.
I mean, for example, iBasso can provide cable with high value (material quality and low impedance) with 100$ package and 60$ can almost get You Tin T3 with also high quality cable included in package.
Market is very competitive and this is not the place where product should "require" You spend more. Get my point?

#2 - if You look at popular IEM designs which are good "average" for everybody (always exceptions though), most of them have "average" length and angle nozzles - Oxygen is not one from those.
I have nothing against tip-rolling (I love tip-rolling as it brings more "options") but when nozzle is short, that tip-rolling gets very limited and thus "sound & fit tuning" also limited. I have extensive collection of different tips for my ear size (S) but for Oxygen there will be only few options with longer tip stem/barrel. I have had similar shape and nozzle length IEMs before and know that would be issue for me. That is one of reasons I went with KPE (which nozzle looks long on pics but actually is same as ZSN or IT01 for example, which have quite "average" nozzle length/angle design).

You and some others were ones who went straight away into defending position and started to compare Oxygen to KPE (guess my avatar and it being current favourite atm affected this).
Really, Oxygen WAS on my choice table... BUT (since You started this comparison Yourself):
1) KPE vs. Oxygen reviews left me with overall impression that they both sound very similar and choice is depending on personal sound signature preferences, gear matchup and money. I`m still thinking same despite many reviews saying Oxygen is better.
It is all about HOW much better? Are You saying that Oxygen is @ another level up? You know there are ppl preferring KPE out there? You know there are reviewers saying that if You already have one then the other is not worth to get regarding price?
Since I got a glimpse chance to get KPE for only 126€ (I would pay full price for them anyway as they are more than worth it) and Oxygen had(has) previouskly mentioned issues, plus my personal preferences were also rather KPE-sided, I went with KPE.
2) They both measure very similarly.
3) KPE has already good quality cable in package (Btw, MD updated their cable to provide better value and quality leaving price same and Lyre Acoustics cables are known to be good).
4) KPE has it`s own issues like heavy weight and finishing which both are no issue to me as I live in relatively cool/dry climate and wear IEMs over-ear with deep fit.
5) KPE also has issue with tips sliding down nozzle and thus changing SQ/fit experience but I rather have this problem (which is easily solved by simple "slip-stop" rings) than short nozzle issue.

is it defensive to say its a logical decision to buy the best iem you can get with a certain budget u set.
I was talking about price vs. value not about certain budget!
If I had 330$ in my pocket for IEM atm - I would probably save up little more and get something else. If it would be max budget regardless what, I would still choose something else because of those mentioned subjective issues.
i really don't get it, u want an objective discussion then atleast provide some onjective argument instead of relying with the subjective "worth value"
I was trying to "slow down" this "upgrade cable definitely needed" train and bring attention to price vs. value.

I had long though before posting this as it may cause flaming and arguing within thread. I decided to explain my views and I hope they are understood now.
I will not post here anymore as I`m not planning to get Oxygen as I already have KPE and was just viewing previously subscribed thread because of purchase interest.

Unsubscribed.

Bye.
 
     Share This Post       
post-14978027
Post #322 of 812

FactoryStock

100+ Head-Fier
Joined
Sep 25, 2017
Messages
179
Reaction score
52
Location
Neitherherenorthere
Joined
Sep 25, 2017
Location
Neitherherenorthere
Posts
179
Likes
52
Did you consider the Sony EX800ST?
Famous for controlled and fast bass, huge soundstage (with very bad isolation, basically semi-open)
Available on Amazon Japan.

Crinacle's measurement
isn't the ex800 and ex1k have treble "problem" some people can't stand the high treble that might be a problem.

but i would rec ex800/ex1k tbh. both have great rep.
Hm... So far I've only tried EX1000 from an owner at an audio store. It has bright vocals but to my ears it sounds deliberately forced clarity rather than natural, so that portion grabbed my attention first before I could try to check the soundstage. I can't handle that kind of fiesty sound for more than half an hour.

Unfortunately, too, isolation is important as well, since I regularly use my IEMs like makeshift earplugs. You know, to just tune out the world. Isolation (and violent treble) was why I gave up on the F9 Pros, and the form factor/isolation is why I didn't gravitate to those various MDRs that stick out of our ears funny. All the same, thanks for the rec.
 
     Share This Post       
post-14978107
Post #323 of 812

warriorpoet

500+ Head-Fier
Joined
Mar 9, 2019
Messages
838
Reaction score
863
Location
United States
Joined
Mar 9, 2019
Location
United States
Posts
838
Likes
863
     Share This Post       
post-14978249
Post #324 of 812

surfgeorge

Member of the Trade: 3D Printed Accessory Designer
Joined
Feb 26, 2018
Messages
1,437
Reaction score
1,217
Location
Austria
Joined
Feb 26, 2018
Location
Austria
Posts
1,437
Likes
1,217
Hm... So far I've only tried EX1000 from an owner at an audio store. It has bright vocals but to my ears it sounds deliberately forced clarity rather than natural, so that portion grabbed my attention first before I could try to check the soundstage. I can't handle that kind of fiesty sound for more than half an hour.

Unfortunately, too, isolation is important as well, since I regularly use my IEMs like makeshift earplugs. You know, to just tune out the world. Isolation (and violent treble) was why I gave up on the F9 Pros, and the form factor/isolation is why I didn't gravitate to those various MDRs that stick out of our ears funny. All the same, thanks for the rec.
@FactoryStock
Based on my experience with the EX800ST I think I understand you.
Since this is the Oxygen thread I will PM you.
 
     Share This Post       
post-14983582
Post #325 of 812

416805

New Head-Fier
Joined
Jan 18, 2015
Messages
0
Reaction score
2
Joined
Jan 18, 2015
Posts
0
Likes
2
20190531_183406.jpg Finally got the cable

using oyaide hpc 26 with rhodium jack

i feel it makes the bass cleaner and upper mid boost.

i really like the upgrade sofar
 
Last edited:
     Share This Post       
  • Like
Reactions: Makahl
post-14983708
Post #326 of 812

HiFlight

Headphoneus Supremus
Joined
Feb 12, 2005
Messages
5,608
Reaction score
1,088
Location
Fort Myers, FL
Joined
Feb 12, 2005
Location
Fort Myers, FL
Posts
5,608
Likes
1,088
Regarding the discussions comparing the KPE to Oxygen...
I have owned both for quite some time and used them interchangeably on an almost daily basis. To my ears, the tonality, headstage, timbre and imaging are very similar. I would be hard-pressed to tell the difference between them based solely on SQ. The more definitive differences are weight, overall size, length of nozzle, cost and durability of finish.

Weight: KPE is heavier, but both were comfortable to me once in place.
Size: Oxygen is significantly smaller if ear size is a consideration.
Nozzle: KPE is considerably longer and if one prefers deep insertion, the O2 will likely fall short (pun intended)
Finish: Some have reported KPE finish issues, primarily in hot, humid environments. The stainless shells of the O2 seem to be imperious to everything except marring or scratching due to mishandling.
Cost: Oxygen is about 80% more expensive.

I hope that this is of some help to those considering which would best meet their personal preferences.
 
Last edited:
post-14983979
Post #327 of 812

Makahl

500+ Head-Fier
Joined
Jun 13, 2016
Messages
688
Reaction score
827
Location
São Paulo
Joined
Jun 13, 2016
Location
São Paulo
Posts
688
Likes
827
I got my Oxygen yesterday and so far it's been less than 24 hours with them but I'm quite enjoying it. I do remember reading mixed opinions about the Oxygen's sub-bass, some reviewers were saying the O2 goes deeper than KPE and others saying KPE has more sub-bass quantity (20-60Hz). At least to me, I'm with the people who find the KPE has more sub-bass oomph. It's even clearer when listening to some electronic stuff such as Jon Hopkins - Emerald Rush (I can remember feeling the sub-bass air popping even in the intro on kpe - which was fantastic for an IEM going that low) or even instrumentals Behind the Shadow Drops - Utopia - which has better texture on O2 but less oomph.

The low-midrange seems where the Oxygen starts to show improvements, it's punchier and faster, perfect for drums and it's playing incredibly well with my favorite bands and sort of what I was looking for, a more engaging version of KPE. Midrange I'd say male vocals are crisper than KPE, female vocals seem ok. Highs, in general, are polite and there's a better extension after the 10kHz which gives a slightly more airy presentation and sense of space, but if you feed Oxygen with an analytical source/amp it sounds too airy which isn't the best pairing IMHO, definitely I'd go with some warmer source if you can.

So, if you like bass-head music Oxygen might not suit you as well as the KPE. If you like instrumentals, progressive stuff Oxygen might give you a more engaging version of the KPE. Some people reported it also improves with the time so my impressions can change in the future.
 
Last edited:
post-14984022
Post #328 of 812

audio123

Reviewer at audio123
Joined
Jan 10, 2016
Messages
8,849
Reaction score
5,195
Joined
Jan 10, 2016
Posts
8,849
Likes
5,195
On a sidenote, the No.3 Ti boasts a more engaging sound than both the KPE & Oxygen with clearer vocals. Have included a comparison of the No.3 Ti vs the Oxygen in my review on the TFZ No.3 Ti. Enjoy & Happy listening, as always! :)

photo_2019-05-29_22-00-11-2.jpg
 
Last edited:
post-14984079
Post #329 of 812

Makahl

500+ Head-Fier
Joined
Jun 13, 2016
Messages
688
Reaction score
827
Location
São Paulo
Joined
Jun 13, 2016
Location
São Paulo
Posts
688
Likes
827
Finally got the cable

using oyaide hpc 26 with rhodium jack

i feel it makes the bass cleaner and upper mid boost.

i really like the upgrade sofar
Where did you buy this Oyaide cable? I'm using a black one from Aliexpress but I replaced the cheap 3.5mm jack for a Neutrik one. At least the aesthetic is better than the stock lol.
 
Last edited:
     Share This Post       
post-14984087
Post #330 of 812

416805

New Head-Fier
Joined
Jan 18, 2015
Messages
0
Reaction score
2
Joined
Jan 18, 2015
Posts
0
Likes
2
I got my Oxygen yesterday and so far it's been less than 24 hours with them but I'm quite enjoying it. I do remember reading mixed opinions about the Oxygen's sub-bass, some reviewers were saying the O2 goes deeper than KPE and others saying KPE has more sub-bass quantity (20-60Hz). At least to me, I'm with the people who find the KPE has more sub-bass oomph. It's even clearer when listening to some electronic stuff such as Jon Hopkins - Emerald Rush (I can remember feeling the sub-bass air popping even in the intro on kpe - which was fantastic for an IEM going that low) or even instrumentals Behind the Shadow Drops - Utopia - which has better texture on O2 but less oomph.

The low-midrange seems where the Oxygen starts to show improvements, it's punchier and faster, perfect for drums and it's playing incredibly well with my favorite bands and sort of what I was looking for, a more engaging version of KPE. Midrange I'd say male vocals are crisper than KPE, female vocals seem ok. Highs, in general, are polite and there's a better extension after the 10kHz which gives a slightly more airy presentation and sense of space, but if you feed Oxygen with an analytical source/amp it sounds too airy which isn't the best pairing IMHO, definitely I'd go with some warmer source if you can.

So, if you like bass-head music Oxygen might not suit you as well as the KPE. If you like instrumentals, progressive stuff Oxygen might give you a more engaging version of the KPE. Some people reported it also improves with the time so my impressions can change in the future.
for bass i agree, KPE have more omph its feels more boosted in those region

but if we see only the technicalities. u can see why people say O2 have better bass. while it might lack the oomph it does have faster attack decay also fast (but not so fast that its gone) over all it feels more tight and less boomy which some people might prefer (i deffo prefer ot over any other bass in this price range)

the only problem for me is the dark sound. while its nice to hear for long hours sometimes u want that treble extension to make things more exciting and "lively"

it also lacked details that the fh5 does which i can say something that i missed.

i do loved most of the thing o2 does but im planning for an upgrade soon while i was satisfied with the purchase i feel its not good enough.

some can say i got the upgraditis. next stop gonna be qdc, maybe im gonna try their new hybrid if i like it thats nice but i don't then i prolly get the VX

Where did you buy this Oyaide cable? I'm using one black from Aliexpress but I replaced the cheap 3.5mm jack for a Neutrik one. At least the aesthetic is better than the stock lol.
its a DIY service from local DIY-er.

its great, improved the bass response by significant margin. its even faster and tighter than before (like if i can give it a number 10-15% this is a sjitty assumption to make it easier to understand cuz there is no way to quantify this). upper mid also improved abit female voice sound sweeter (but still need some improvements) treble is still meh i guess nothing can help this beside eq.
 
Last edited:
     Share This Post       
  • Like
Reactions: Makahl

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 2, Guests: 3)

Top