Sony WH 1000XM2 or ATH-M50X

  1. macieqq
    Ok, so the title says it all...

    Recently I have purchased a new pair of headphones for gaming purposes and I am quite happy with my choice (which was Sennheiser Game One).

    Now I am looking for something different - headphones, which will be used for listening to music mostly from my smartphone.

    I wear glasses so I need these new headphones to be super comfy as I will be using them for about 5-8 hours a day. My first choice was Bose QC35 as they are awesome when it comes to being comfortable. However, I didn't really like the sound of those cans so after trying out Sony WH 1000XM2 I decided to switch. These are great - they are comfortable, they have ANC and all but... they feel a bit cheap to me (not to mention cracking issues with MDR 1000X).

    As I work in the office, ANC is a good feature but I won't be able to fully use it as I need to hear someone sitting behind me calling my name from time to time. It would be super awkward and tiring if they had to come to my desk everytime they wanted something from me. ANC is cool for flights but I travel once a month tops. Being wireless is a plus of course but then again, I sit next to my desk almost all day long...

    So it struck me - wouldn't it be better to just buy some classy cans like ATH-M50X for 1/3 of the price? The problem is I haven't tried those and I am not really sure what to expect (unfortunately most of the stores next to where I live do not have the demo M50Xs which I could try out).

    I could really use some help deciding what to get. Maybe you have some other recommendations taking what I wrote above into account?

    Thanks in advance.
     
    Last edited: Nov 10, 2017
  2. cossix
    The M50x isn't classy at all IMO :p HD598 is classy, 650 is classy, Momentum 2 is classy, B&W P7/LCD2/ZMF Eikon are all classy. The M50x are very durable but have been labeled "the Beats of the Audiophile world" by many.

    As for sound, what type of sound signature do you like? The M50x are reportedly V shaped
     
  3. macieqq
    Thanks for replying so quickly.

    I am not an audiophile by any means and I don't really know all the terminology. I either like the sound or I don't :)

    But I can tell you that - I've had HD598 for a couple of days before I returned them. I have also tried 650s in the store and I didn't like the sound of both at all - it was too flat for me. My Sennheisers Game One are great for gaming purposes but when I listen to music - they are meh. I like a little more bass.

    I would really like to get these Sonys WH 1000XM2 but I have two issues with them - they feel cheap as f... and I am not sure if they are worth the price over something simple like the mentioned M50X for example.
     
  4. cossix
    The M50x are definitely known to sound more exciting than the 598 and 650 so maybe that's what you need! To me, the Audio Technicas in that line don't feel "flimsy" cheap, but feel "plastic" cheap. It's a very durable plastic but it's just not my style. I'd say go for it though, they may work for you
     
  5. macieqq
    Well, I've had some time to think today about the new headphones. I wrote down everything that I'd need from them and it turns out that I need the most to be able hear people in my office while listening to my music. In this case, shouldn't I go with open-back headphones instead? I know they leak sound but I don't really care, since people in my office listen to radio through speakers anyway. Having open-backs would let me notice when someone from behind calls my name I suppose. What do you think?

    If that would be the way to go - what would you recommend under $300? I know HD600s are tempting but I already own a pair of Sennheisers and I'd like to give something else a try.

    On the other hand, I've heard that Sony WH 1000XM2 have ambient mode which could probably solve my problem. However, I am not sure about the sound quality in that mode...
     
    Last edited: Nov 11, 2017

Share This Page