Crazier than that, is the way people perceive these or any other headphones because of price. For quite a while now they have become rather affordable and are considered "entry level" audiophile headphones. It becomes one of those "well these are great for the price" but obviously lack in x,y,z.
If someone was to buy these for $300, all of a sudden the x,y,z bits can be seen as mere properties that contribute to it's excellent signature.
Not saying everyone is like this. There are people that are stone cold objective about things, even if they made the "wrong" decision to buy an expensive product. They make the best reviewers