Samsung YP-Q1 JEB vs. Sony NWZ S638

[sennmann]

Hello guys,
i need a new MP3-Player to replace my old Meizu. I only need it to hear music, mostly rock and i enjoy to use the EQ and the other sound setting the meizu gave me! So which one of the both at the top listed, you would buy?

 

[Miyazaki]

Sony. I've tried both and think the Sony player sounds better. I also found the touch controls on the Samsung Q1 quite finnicky.

 

[insicor]

The Q1 is just a cheap version of the P2 with weirder controls. Get the Sony.

 

[tkl.hui]

I've never tried the sony, but i personally own the Q1 and i love the DNSE eq thing. It seems to find the right eq automatically depending on what song i have playing. Sound quality to my Denon D1001s is pretty good too.