Quietest HD/Headphone-out mp3 player?
post-792641
Thread Starter
Post #1 of 12

jpelg

Needs a regular fix of 'Fi
'06 Nat Meet Co-Coordinator
Joined
Jan 19, 2002
Messages
8,675
Reaction score
26
Location
The Elm City
Joined
Jan 19, 2002
Location
The Elm City
Posts
8,675
Likes
26
My six-month old Archos Jukebox Recorder 20 is developing a very noisy hard drive. Kind of a high-pitched whine. The noise is prominent every time the disk spins up (boot-up, file navigation, playing music), and is heard not only externally (with the unit held up to my ear), but also thru the headphone-out, which is extremely annoying thru my Ety's (ER4P's). I've read where others have experienced this as well, even though this did not seem to be the case for mine until now. I don't have reason to question the integrity of the hard drive ATM, but that is always a possibility, of course.

My question is that, since a replacement warranty was purchased thru CC when I got the Archos, I can probably return it for a substitute. Of the players currently available at CC, which has the quietest hard drive and/or headphone-out?

Creative Nomad Zen Xtra 30G - $269
RCA 40 GB Lyra - $299
Rio Karma 20GB - $299
Apple iPod - $299-$499 (15-40GB)

I loved my old, 2nd-gen iPod (10G), and only sold it to get a bigger HD and a digital-out. I no longer require the digital-out, and never should have sold it. I would have to pay the difference between the original Archos price ($229) & the new player.

Are any of these players worth considering, or are some of the others on the market leaps and bounds better that I should consider buying somewhere else? Is the hard-drive noise prominent on most HD-based players (I don't recall this being a problem at all on my old iPod)? I've even considered the possiblity of going back to a CD-based mp3 player like the iRiver 550 if that were quiet, except that the convenience factor of a DAP is so great.

Any thoughts are appreciated. TIA.
 
     Share This Post       
post-792646
Post #2 of 12

Bolt San

500+ Head-Fier
Joined
Feb 29, 2004
Messages
959
Reaction score
10
Joined
Feb 29, 2004
Posts
959
Likes
10
Karma and iPod both have very quiet hard drives, and I don't hear them with canalphones, or anything else.

I don't hear static with either, also.
In terms of their other features I'd pick the Karma, though.
 
     Share This Post       
post-792783
Post #3 of 12

halcyon

Headphoneus Supremus
Joined
Oct 21, 2002
Messages
1,819
Reaction score
173
Joined
Oct 21, 2002
Posts
1,819
Likes
173
I can hear the hard drive spin up on my Karma 20 GB (through the headphones). This means that the audio output isn't perfectly isolated from the digital/hd part.

Of course it is audible without headphones as well, because the case doesn't dampen the start up sound inside the enclosure.

However, during normal (non-classical) music I cannot hear this sound.

For me Karma is sufficiently good. All I would like to have is better battery times
 
     Share This Post       
post-792812
Post #4 of 12

TheBigDu

Head-Fier
Joined
Apr 5, 2004
Messages
84
Reaction score
0
Joined
Apr 5, 2004
Posts
84
Likes
0
only time i ever hear the HDD on my iHP-120 is when using the internal mic. to record something...I sure as hell don't hear it when listening to music
 
     Share This Post       
post-794067
Post #5 of 12

wolfen68

Headphoneus Supremus
Joined
Jun 4, 2003
Messages
3,672
Reaction score
110
Joined
Jun 4, 2003
Posts
3,672
Likes
110
I can hear the hard drive through the headphones on my Archos R20 Version 1....when I use my E3's. They seem to be sensitive enough to pick it up. My other headphones don't reveal that noise.
 
     Share This Post       
post-794096
Post #6 of 12

Bolt San

500+ Head-Fier
Joined
Feb 29, 2004
Messages
959
Reaction score
10
Joined
Feb 29, 2004
Posts
959
Likes
10
Quote:

Originally Posted by halcyon
I can hear the hard drive spin up on my Karma 20 GB (through the headphones). This means that the audio output isn't perfectly isolated from the digital/hd part.

Of course it is audible without headphones as well, because the case doesn't dampen the start up sound inside the enclosure.

However, during normal (non-classical) music I cannot hear this sound.

For me Karma is sufficiently good. All I would like to have is better battery times



Karma has one of the best battery lifes, what format are you using for your files?
 
     Share This Post       
post-794108
Post #7 of 12

ITZBITZ

100+ Head-Fier
Joined
Oct 31, 2003
Messages
382
Reaction score
11
Joined
Oct 31, 2003
Posts
382
Likes
11
iPOD 40GB

Very nice build quality, easy to use, you've had one before and liked it and it now supports loseless files for maximum quality (even though a 160K M4A is probably fine for on-the-go listening and battery life).
 
     Share This Post       
post-816404
Post #8 of 12

halcyon

Headphoneus Supremus
Joined
Oct 21, 2002
Messages
1,819
Reaction score
173
Joined
Oct 21, 2002
Posts
1,819
Likes
173
Quote:

Originally Posted by Bolt San
Karma has one of the best battery lifes, what format are you using for your files?


Yes, Karma does have good comparative batter life, when comparison is done against other HD players.

However, as I also use portable cd players, there is no comparison on that front.

I use all formats flac, mp3 and ogg. I know that lower bit rate mp3/ogg files conserve battery better.

I'm considering switching over to OGG aoTuV beta 2 + QKTune beta 3.2 for my portable encoded files at 128kbps.

I participated in the latest 128 kbps listening test published at Hydrogen Audio and I couldn't distinguish between the original and properly encoded OGG (at 128kbps) on many of the samples.

regards,
halcyon
 
     Share This Post       
post-816421
Post #9 of 12

rickcr42

Are YOU talkin' to me?
Joined
Jun 21, 2001
Messages
13,874
Reaction score
13
Joined
Jun 21, 2001
Posts
13,874
Likes
13
any mechanical storage device will produce some noise ,and it will increase over time as parts wear

the only way you get absolute silence is with a toally electronic storage medium like compact flah but the storage compacity would not be close


everything is a comprimise ,you decide on the priorities and then choose accordingly
 
     Share This Post       
post-816422
Post #10 of 12

rickcr42

Are YOU talkin' to me?
Joined
Jun 21, 2001
Messages
13,874
Reaction score
13
Joined
Jun 21, 2001
Posts
13,874
Likes
13
any mechanical storage device will produce some noise ,and it will increase over time as parts wear

the only way you get absolute silence is with a toally electronic storage medium like compact flash but the storage compacity and features would not be close


everything is a comprimise ,you decide on the priorities and then choose accordingly
 
     Share This Post       
post-824959
Post #12 of 12

RunsWithScissors

100+ Head-Fier
Joined
Sep 13, 2002
Messages
349
Reaction score
1
Joined
Sep 13, 2002
Posts
349
Likes
1
Quote:

Originally Posted by rickcr42
any mechanical storage device will produce some noise ,and it will increase over time as parts wear

the only way you get absolute silence is with a toally electronic storage medium like compact flash but the storage compacity and features would not be close


everything is a comprimise ,you decide on the priorities and then choose accordingly



My iPod's drive is still as quiet as the day I got it. It is essentially silent - I can only notice it spin up when I transfer songs via my PC. I never hear it when I listen with headphones with or without music. I use Shure E5 which are very sensitive when it comes to the noise floor on your source and there is virtually no background noise from the iPod. I also don't hear the drive spin through the E5 when it does spin up to reload the buffer while playing music.

While I completely agree with rickcr42 statements in general, a real world comparison of jpelg's 6 month old archos and my 14 month old 2G iPod seems to make a statement about product/parts quality difference (and perhaps also build quality and design) and how they hold up over time.
 
     Share This Post       

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 1)

Top