Luis Mad
Headphoneus Supremus
Bernstein
Tonight from West Side Story
Juan Diego Florez and Nadine Sierra
Tonight from West Side Story
Juan Diego Florez and Nadine Sierra
VERY well played indeed.
One thing is sure, I'll never play it even close to that well.
But I do prefer to hear it played at a slightly slower tempo.
My sheet music states Adagio sostenuto "sustained".
Most tutorials I have used to learn to play the first movement,clock in at around 6-7 minutes. And at that tempo I feel I get enough time to really saviour some of the most amazing chords.
And to me Adagio means slow.
Why would he add sostenuto to the Adagio if he didn´t want it played sostenuto?
But many other great pianists like Barenboim also play at a similar faster tempo once the March theme begins.
But Beethoven also wrote Marcia funebre for his Eroica and that's a very slow March.
My guess is both from listening and playing the first movement of the Moonlight that he had an almost similar tempo in mind as for the Eroica?
And in spite of a imho, painfully slow Appassionata recording ,Glenn Gould played the Moonlight way too fast imho.
But I am happy to have bookmarked his superslow Appassionata ,very helpful when learning.
GG's Moonlight no thanks.
Levit's yes indeed.
Cheers CC
Hello CM,I don't think there is any reason to suspect that he indicated another tempo in his manuscript than in the first published version which was in 1802 which has both Adagio sostenuto and tutto siempre senza sordino. But apparently the first page of the manuscript is lost.Good points as usual, Christer.
What tempo did Beethoven indicate on the autograph manuscript?
With His symphonies, there has been a recurring "controversy" over "literal" interpretations of His tempo markings (when there are any).
It may be something similar with his sonatas?
cheers
CM
Hello CM,I don't think there is any reason to suspect that he indicated another tempo in his manuscript than in the first published version which was in 1802 which has both Adagio sostenuto and tutto siempre senza sordino. But apparently the first page of the manuscript is lost.
Oh yes lots of discussions around tempos and metronome indications regarding the symphonies. My only personal take in most cases is that too many conductors ignore the imho very important 1st violins on the left and 2nd violins on the right seating.
There are lots of dialogues between 1st and 2nd violins both in his symphonies and concertos that get lost with modern seating ie both together on the left.
PS .Did you notice that Die Salzburger Festspiele 2020 did allow an audience at some concerts at the Centenary in August.
If I had known, I would have gone there.
It's been too many years since last time.
Cheers CC