older gaming pc: should i use xp or win7?

Oct 26, 2009 at 8:59 AM Thread Starter Post #1 of 18

uzziah

Headphoneus Supremus
Joined
Oct 15, 2004
Posts
4,049
Likes
14
so, this system has been a great "investment". i've been able to do a couple minor upgrades, and unless i'm very much mistaken (and let me know if i am), it still can run most games today pretty well. my thinking is that i'll probably do one more upgrade on this system in a year or so: video card, and then i'll replace the whole thing.

here it is:
asrock dual-sata2 mobo s939 (considered a great overclocker, i have yet to try but will do so)
9600gt gpu
a64 4000 x2 dual core cpu
2gb basic DDR ram
standard 7200rpm 250gb hdd (will probably nab a bigger one eventually and add it in

excellent cpu cooling and good overall case cooling; recently dug out all the dust that had accumulated and jesus did that make a difference, this box is 5 years old or so, i originally had a basic gpu, and a single core cpu, and 1gb of ram; i upgraded those three only a year ago or less, and got great deals on the upgrades since at that point they were already off the bleeding edge

now, this machine isn't just for gaming, but that is the only thing i do to tax the system; will be doing a little audio and video editing, but nothing major


now, the question i wanted to ask is: i am going to do a windows reinstall real soon, should i put win7 on it? will it be faster or slower with that? i really don't want to hear about "future proofing", because first: it's a laughable idea with computers (yeah, we all got our money's worth with our 64-bits on our athlon cpus : ) ), and this computer is only going to be with me for another year or two, maybe three max if i stop to care about high end games. even now i'm not asking to run the high end stuff on max.

i'd like to be able to run new games on medium graphics, and games that are a few years old on high, or nearly high

since i wrote all this i guess i'll actually ask all the questions i wanted to:



1. should i install xp or win7? will be doing so VERY soon
2. am i correct that with gaming my GPU is still my weakest point? am i right that a gpu upgrad at some time would be the last worthwhile thing to do? getting a new cpu or ram for this is silly as it is a very old platform
3. adjunct: i am assuming that the fact that i have DDR ram, an older cpu architecture and mobo architecture is not THAT big a deal. Am i right about that? i'm assuming that even though my architecture is pretty old, that it still is nearly as fast as today's systems, yes?


thanks for the help. money is an issue. i'm all about the bang for buck, and i'm not doing any upgrades right now; i have been using my xbox360 for games, and this system (i'm afraid to admit) has mostly just been sitting unused. since i mostly play games alone i'm planning to sell off the ybox and all games and such and just use the PC (i also want a good driving wheel and flightstick.......if you could suggest i would appreciate.....and games to match). i already have the wired xbox360 controller that is the perfect gamepad, and of course coming from headfi i have kickass headphones and a zhaolu outboard dac/amp


ok.............i typed far too much, but i want to thank y'all in advance for helping a brotha out
 
Oct 26, 2009 at 9:06 AM Post #2 of 18
You should be alright running Win7 with a dual core. You've certainly got enough ram.
 
Oct 26, 2009 at 9:11 AM Post #3 of 18
7.

The 9600GT a great GPU, even now. You've got enough RAM, the CPU is the weak point IMO. But if you were to upgrade that you'd also need to upgrade the mobo and RAM. So I'd wait until you have enough funds then to a full system overhaul.
 
Oct 26, 2009 at 9:48 AM Post #5 of 18
Well Windows 7 runs fine (with Aero off) on a Viliv S5 (1.33GHz single core Atom, 1GB of ram and an Intel integrated videocard using shared memory).
 
Oct 26, 2009 at 12:07 PM Post #6 of 18
Quote:

Originally Posted by nsx_23 /img/forum/go_quote.gif
If you're unsure, use the microsoft upgrade advisor to test.


I'd recommend do this on that "old" computer because if the motherboard chipset can support 64-bit memory addressing under Windows 7, this machine would be a fantastic machine for general computing once the memory is upgraded to 4 GB.
good2.gif
 
Oct 26, 2009 at 2:23 PM Post #7 of 18
My computer is around the same spec as yours (Same GPU, almost same cpu and 2gb ram)

And i find Win7 is faster and more responsive compared to Win xp which i used previously

However, i just upgraded my 2gb ram to 6gb ram which i find it worthwhile to do so
 
Oct 26, 2009 at 2:24 PM Post #8 of 18
I'd say stick with XP if you already own a copy, if you have to pay for a new OS get 7. IMHO motherboard, ram speed and cpu are going to be your major bottlenecks with that system.
 
Oct 26, 2009 at 7:20 PM Post #10 of 18
Price shouldn't matter. You can get Win7 for 30 bucks.
 
Nov 28, 2009 at 12:18 AM Post #12 of 18
thanks folks; well that's very good to know; i thought the vid card would be the bottleneck with games, but i guess not; very valuable info and i really appreciate it; DDR ram is hard to find now, but if i find it cheap i'll grab more; s939 cpu's are impossible to find, and they don't come that much faster anyway, so i think upgrading the cpu without a new mobo (and new ram with that of course) is not worth it; but i'll put some feelers out and maybe find a used cheap killer 939 cpu; i got a great cpu cooler on it and i need to learn to overclock, but this cpu is supposed to OC very well (previous owner got 3ghz, on water though)

very cool, so perhaps when i start to upgrade, i may start with gpu because i can get a killer gpu and transfer that to new pc with new mobo, cpu, ram; i assume pci-express is still the format for the foreseeable future eh?

i won't have to buy the OS, so yeah, i guess i'll go for win7, no reason why not i guess

my hdd is your standard 7200rpm drive, i assume that that's not a bottleneck really

i'd need new psu if i put any more power into it anyway, so i think i'll be just fine as it is for the moment

thanks folks, and any other advice would be well welcome
 
Nov 28, 2009 at 12:22 AM Post #13 of 18
Quote:

Originally Posted by SactoMan101 /img/forum/go_quote.gif
I'd recommend do this on that "old" computer because if the motherboard chipset can support 64-bit memory addressing under Windows 7, this machine would be a fantastic machine for general computing once the memory is upgraded to 4 GB.
good2.gif




can anyone tell me if the asrock dual-sata2 board (socket 939) can do this? this was a cool board, quite popular with OC'ers because it has both agp (is that what that old vid card format was called? i think i'm typing it wrong), and pci-express slots, and it can even be upgradded to an AM2 cpu, and apparently it OC's pretty decently; of course it's outdated now and i certainly won't perform any heroic measures to keep it alive, just run it as is until i need an entire new setup; i think all in all, for how many years i've had it, it has a very good price for performance setup

btw: i have a 1080p tv that i will run on, so ideally i'd run games at 1080p; of course if i have to do 720p then so be it

sorry for the long typing, i do appreciate the help
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top