At lunch I decided to head over to Guitar Center and try a pair of M50's and then to the Apple Store to try a pair of V-Moda crossfades.
Before leaving I synced up a few songs I wanted to listen to on my iPhone (this and my MBP will be my most frequently used media players). I headed down to the Apple store and tried on the Crossfades. I love the way they look and they felt pretty good but the cups felt a little small and I don't have big ears. I hooked them up to my iPhone and listened and really liked the way they sounded however I felt that it sounded 'soft' or as if there was a thick fabric over the sound. Specifically I listened to Hotel California (instrumental version from "Hell Freezes Over") by the Eagles and Savior (Rise Against) (both 320kbps - I know, I know..) among others and was pleased by the sound. I wasn't pleased by how much sound the crossfades let in, nor the fact that even in the Apple Store, which has a lot of loud ambient noise the leakage was pretty bad. That said however they sounded so much better than the V-Moda IEMs I got at costco a few years ago and the Sony MDREX38iP's that I was using currently.
Then I drove over to GuitarCenter on a whim that they would even have the M50's in stock let alone a pair to demo. I put them on and they felt almost too big, I adjusted and they were immediately quite comfortable. I plugged them into my iPhone and fired up Hotel California.
Sweet mother of god.
I think my face started to melt. Immediately that 'muffled' soft sound I had heard in Hotel California was gone. Instead I heard individual claps from the audience and the sound of a finger running down the guitar string. Not to sound too dramatic but it sounded like I was there. The bass wasn't muddy but instead had a very specific punch to it. I was very pleased. Next I fired up Savior and truly experienced what 'soundstage' is. In the first 10 seconds of vocals in that song it finally sounded like the music wasn't 'in my head' but instead it felt like I was in the studio and could point to where his voice was coming from. I fired up some other songs and was just floored by the clarity, the bass, the mids, everything.
Needless to say I came back, traded the Apple Store card for an Amazon card and just ordered the M50's. I can't wait to get them although I have a feeling I'll just have to leave them on for a day or so and break them in. I wanted the Crossfades so bad, mostly because of the look and the fact that they had the iPod controls and mic but after comparing the SQ from them both I'm glad I'm going with the M50's.
Thank you Head-Fi, had I not known about this forum I would have happily bought Aviators/Beats/Crossfades and never known what my music was meant to sound like.