NEW - Campfire Comet and Atlas
post-14975776
Post #2,761 of 3,273

subguy812

Reviewer: Audio Rabbit Hole
Joined
Jan 30, 2013
Messages
4,706
Reaction score
3,580
Location
House of the Rising Sun
Joined
Jan 30, 2013
Location
House of the Rising Sun
Posts
4,706
Likes
3,580
Interested to hear if you bought the Atlas or the IMR R1? I am thinking Atlas or IMR Zenith? Looking for bass and large detail soundstage. My over ears are HD800s.
The Zenith is more forward and in your face with it's sound. Excellent wide stage and can be a little aggressive in the top end. Very snappy and full bass sound, the black filter is default and I stuck with it on the Zenith as opposed to the pink one on the OG R1.

The Atlas is one of the most engaging IEM's I have. Allow yourself to adapt to the sound as it definitely is not a "first listen" IEM. The bass is deep and the treble extends well north, there is sparkle up top.
 
post-14975792
Post #2,762 of 3,273

Matty Allen

New Head-Fier
Joined
May 15, 2019
Messages
27
Reaction score
16
Location
Brighton UK and Pokhara Nepal
Joined
May 15, 2019
Location
Brighton UK and Pokhara Nepal
Posts
27
Likes
16
The Zenith is more forward and in your face with it's sound. Excellent wide stage and can be a little aggressive in the top end. Very snappy and full bass sound, the black filter is default and I stuck with it on the Zenith as opposed to the pink one on the OG R1.

The Atlas is one of the most engaging IEM's I have. Allow yourself to adapt to the sound as it definitely is not a "first listen" IEM. The bass is deep and the treble extends well north, there is sparkle up top.
If you had to choose just one, Zenith or Atlas, which would you choose and why? I am looking to buy just one and keep it.
From what you say the Zenith has the bigger soundstage?
When you say the Atlas isn't a first listen iem what do you mean?
Atlas is 3 times the price of Zenith, which I am happy to pay if it's worth it. Though I'm getting the impresion they are not so far apart. Is that true?
Wish I could demo them both.

On a secondary note, I see you have Legend X... I wonder how they compare...
 
Last edited:
     Share This Post       
post-14975827
Post #2,763 of 3,273

subguy812

Reviewer: Audio Rabbit Hole
Joined
Jan 30, 2013
Messages
4,706
Reaction score
3,580
Location
House of the Rising Sun
Joined
Jan 30, 2013
Location
House of the Rising Sun
Posts
4,706
Likes
3,580
If you had to choose just one, Zenith or Atlas, which would you choose and why? I am looking to buy just one and keep it.
From what you say the Zenith has the bigger soundstage?
When you say the Atlas isn't a first listen iem what do you mean?
Atlas is 3 times the price of Zenith, which I am happy to pay if it's worth it. Though I'm getting the impression they are not so far apart. Is that true?
Wish I could demo them both.
Matty let me say this, I am detecting that you appear to be swaying toward the Zenith, mainly because of price. If you are looking to me to make you feel it is the right decision to purchase an IEM that costs 1/3 less, I am not going to do that. I try to focus on sound only because what someone can afford is personal, to me, I may think neither is expensive.

If purchased new, Atlas has a wall of bass out of the box, but DD burn-in or growing accustomed to the signature, it quickly becomes more tame, that is why I caution you on drawing conclusions on first listen.

The Zenith may have a touch wider stage, but for the fuller sound of the Atlas the gap isn't the widest. I think there is more space around the notes in the Zenith which may give the illusion that it has a monster stage.

Both have their merits, the Zenith is customizable, the Atlas isn't. The stock cable with the Atlas is fantastic, the while the Zenith cable is better than the OG, it is still springy and a bit unwieldy.

Maybe buy both...used Atlas on the boards for 875 currently and a B-Stock Zenith from the IMR site.
 
Last edited:
     Share This Post       
  • Like
Reactions: Matty Allen
post-14975926
Post #2,764 of 3,273

Matty Allen

New Head-Fier
Joined
May 15, 2019
Messages
27
Reaction score
16
Location
Brighton UK and Pokhara Nepal
Joined
May 15, 2019
Location
Brighton UK and Pokhara Nepal
Posts
27
Likes
16
Matty let me say this, I am detecting that you appear to be swaying toward the Zenith, mainly because of price. If you are looking to me to make you feel it is the right decision to purchase an IEM that costs 1/3 less, I am not going to do that. I try to focus on sound only because what someone can afford is personal, to me, I may think neither is expensive.

If purchased new, Atlas has a wall of bass out of the box, but DD burn-in or growing accustomed to the signature, it quickly becomes more tame, that is why I caution you on drawing conclusions on first listen.

The Zenith may have a touch wider stage, but for the fuller sound of the Atlas the gap isn't the widest. I think there is more space around the notes in the Zenith which may give the illusion that it has a monster stage.

Both have their merits, the Zenith is customizable, the Atlas isn't. The stock cable with the Atlas is fantastic, the while the Zenith cable is better than the OG, it is still springy and a bit unwieldy.

Maybe buy both...used Atlas on the boards for 875 currently and a B-Stock Zenith from the IMR site.
Thank you for sharing your thoughts and knowledge. In truth I can happily afford one of them but can't justify both. I also travel full time and its just more stuff. I guess I am drawn to the soundstage of the Zenith as my over ears are HD800s and I love the detailed soundstage of them. However... if the Atlas is the most engaging with a fuller sound... and not miles away in sense of soundstage.... perhaps Atlas is the way.
 
     Share This Post       
  • Like
Reactions: subguy812
post-14976178
Post #2,765 of 3,273

7VIIlI777IIlIV7l

New Head-Fier
Joined
Aug 23, 2018
Messages
46
Reaction score
35
Location
France
Joined
Aug 23, 2018
Location
France
Posts
46
Likes
35
I cannot get my Atlas to not flex with silicon tips, I've tried at least 100 times and there is not even 1 time where I could have a clean sound in both of my ears. I mean it happened once but as I moved my head it was gone. I've tried final tips, madarin symbio W peel and symbio W.
I think I would prefer the sound with silicon but it's not like I have a choice here.

I'm going to stick with foam only and gonna order some comply to test as even the smaller marshmallow are a bit too big for my ears
 
     Share This Post       
  • Like
Reactions: Tristy
post-14976184
Post #2,766 of 3,273

Tristy

500+ Head-Fier
Joined
Nov 21, 2018
Messages
818
Reaction score
637
Location
England
Joined
Nov 21, 2018
Location
England
Posts
818
Likes
637
I cannot get my Atlas to not flex with silicon tips, I've tried at least 100 times and there is not even 1 time where I could have a clean sound in both of my ears. I mean it happened once but as I moved my head it was gone. I've tried final tips, madarin symbio W peel and symbio W.
I think I would prefer the sound with silicon but it's not like I have a choice here.

I'm going to stick with foam only and gonna order some comply to test as even the smaller marshmallow are a bit too big for my ears
I had this problem initially too, its just a matter of getting used to inserting them. I find when using symbios make sure your squeeze the tip first to make the foams smaller and then insert the Atlas at an angle so that its kind aiming towards your eyeballs... It sounds strange but I found that I had minimal driver flex doing this and and had no cutting out when moving my head. I also found I had better results when not inserting so deep.
 
     Share This Post       
post-14976486
Post #2,767 of 3,273

tlcocks

100+ Head-Fier
Joined
Sep 2, 2018
Messages
102
Reaction score
46
Location
Florida
Joined
Sep 2, 2018
Location
Florida
Posts
102
Likes
46
Matty let me say this, I am detecting that you appear to be swaying toward the Zenith, mainly because of price. If you are looking to me to make you feel it is the right decision to purchase an IEM that costs 1/3 less, I am not going to do that. I try to focus on sound only because what someone can afford is personal, to me, I may think neither is expensive.

If purchased new, Atlas has a wall of bass out of the box, but DD burn-in or growing accustomed to the signature, it quickly becomes more tame, that is why I caution you on drawing conclusions on first listen.

The Zenith may have a touch wider stage, but for the fuller sound of the Atlas the gap isn't the widest. I think there is more space around the notes in the Zenith which may give the illusion that it has a monster stage.

Both have their merits, the Zenith is customizable, the Atlas isn't. The stock cable with the Atlas is fantastic, the while the Zenith cable is better than the OG, it is still springy and a bit unwieldy.

Maybe buy both...used Atlas on the boards for 875 currently and a B-Stock Zenith from the IMR site.
I’ve now got about 500 hours on my Atlas. It sounds very different (to the better) now vs new. Bass has tightened up. Mids are excellent. Treble is smoothest best top octave I’ve heard in iem. I love them more every day!
 
post-14980142
Post #2,768 of 3,273

Pott

100+ Head-Fier
Joined
Sep 11, 2009
Messages
380
Reaction score
33
Joined
Sep 11, 2009
Posts
380
Likes
33
I got the Atlas through the open-box set. I couldn't quite believe the price (799!), so in the cart it went. They got here today.

It's funny... I always say I prefer more neutral, less fatiguing, clear sound from my IEMs. But those I end-up enjoying the most are the power kings; my Dekoni Blues at the office (replacing my Meze 99 Neo), the CA Lyra II (which had fit issues unfortunately but sound huge), my InEarz Euphoria (vs. the Ultimate Ears IE7s which have a much more learn, mids-oriented sound) and now, the Atlas.

They're really quite something. I'm listening to Grand Magus' last album, with its dark production, and still, it works. The bass is huge but I can still track it accurately in the soundspace. It could do with a smidge more mids, especially in the busier spots in some songs. But the treble, soundstage, and bass are a thing to behold.

HUGE bonuses:
* Inserting them isn't a while process like it can be with other IEMs (my left ear canal is tiny, which restricts my choices)
* They FIT. In itself, that'd make them a very rare thing indeed, even without accounting for the huge sound!

I also have the Lyra II and Polaris II from CA. The Polaris fit, the Lyra do not. I got the Lyra for cheaper than the Polaris (Massdrop), but I'd say it's the better IEM (...and indeed they cost more new!). Three solid choices though, with a lot of power and bass from the Lyra II, a little more balanced tonality from the Polaris, and Ultimate Power from the Atlas.
 
     Share This Post       
post-14980241
Post #2,769 of 3,273

Tristy

500+ Head-Fier
Joined
Nov 21, 2018
Messages
818
Reaction score
637
Location
England
Joined
Nov 21, 2018
Location
England
Posts
818
Likes
637
I got the Atlas through the open-box set. I couldn't quite believe the price (799!), so in the cart it went. They got here today.

It's funny... I always say I prefer more neutral, less fatiguing, clear sound from my IEMs. But those I end-up enjoying the most are the power kings; my Dekoni Blues at the office (replacing my Meze 99 Neo), the CA Lyra II (which had fit issues unfortunately but sound huge), my InEarz Euphoria (vs. the Ultimate Ears IE7s which have a much more learn, mids-oriented sound) and now, the Atlas.

They're really quite something. I'm listening to Grand Magus' last album, with its dark production, and still, it works. The bass is huge but I can still track it accurately in the soundspace. It could do with a smidge more mids, especially in the busier spots in some songs. But the treble, soundstage, and bass are a thing to behold.

HUGE bonuses:
* Inserting them isn't a while process like it can be with other IEMs (my left ear canal is tiny, which restricts my choices)
* They FIT. In itself, that'd make them a very rare thing indeed, even without accounting for the huge sound!

I also have the Lyra II and Polaris II from CA. The Polaris fit, the Lyra do not. I got the Lyra for cheaper than the Polaris (Massdrop), but I'd say it's the better IEM (...and indeed they cost more new!). Three solid choices though, with a lot of power and bass from the Lyra II, a little more balanced tonality from the Polaris, and Ultimate Power from the Atlas.
I was curious about getting the Polaris II before taking the plunge for the Solaris, im glad I did but im still very curious about how the Polaris stacks up against the Atlas! Can you please give a comparison once you've burnt them in?
 
     Share This Post       
post-14981283
Post #2,771 of 3,273

subguy812

Reviewer: Audio Rabbit Hole
Joined
Jan 30, 2013
Messages
4,706
Reaction score
3,580
Location
House of the Rising Sun
Joined
Jan 30, 2013
Location
House of the Rising Sun
Posts
4,706
Likes
3,580
Thank you for sharing your thoughts and knowledge. In truth I can happily afford one of them but can't justify both. I also travel full time and its just more stuff. I guess I am drawn to the soundstage of the Zenith as my over ears are HD800s and I love the detailed soundstage of them. However... if the Atlas is the most engaging with a fuller sound... and not miles away in sense of soundstage.... perhaps Atlas is the way.
Let us know what you decide
 
     Share This Post       
post-14981286
Post #2,772 of 3,273

Tristy

500+ Head-Fier
Joined
Nov 21, 2018
Messages
818
Reaction score
637
Location
England
Joined
Nov 21, 2018
Location
England
Posts
818
Likes
637
     Share This Post       
post-14982522
Post #2,774 of 3,273

journeyman63

New Head-Fier
Joined
Apr 7, 2018
Messages
45
Reaction score
17
Location
Oregon, USA
Joined
Apr 7, 2018
Location
Oregon, USA
Posts
45
Likes
17
Congratulations, can you post a comment about fit and comfort? im looking to buy these and dont want to regret it.
I received my open-box Atlas yesterday. I haven't had a lot of time with them, but in terms of fit and comfort, I find them to work really well with the foam tips that were installed on them. I believe it's a medium-sized tip, which is what usually works well for me. I've settled on wearing them with the cord over my ears. They are comfortable and there is no driver flex that I can detect. Everything in the box looks brand new to me, so I have no regrets about not having bought a new pair.
 
     Share This Post       
post-14982756
Post #2,775 of 3,273

macdonjh

500+ Head-Fier
Joined
Sep 16, 2015
Messages
621
Reaction score
685
Joined
Sep 16, 2015
Posts
621
Likes
685
I just received some polished stainless goodness from Oregon today. I am performing my first hour of in-ear burn in now.
 
     Share This Post       

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 1)

Top