Quote:
Originally posted by bubbaj
I recently purchased a pair of Etymotic ER-4Ps. Now I’m looking for a portable music source. I’m considering the SlimX CD/Mp3 player, the Rio Volt SP250, or a NEX II MP3 player.
I’ve read that some have said the SlimX has a little hiss, yet others have said no. This would drive me crazy. Can anyone give any input here?
Do any of these units support playlists? If so, how are they created?
Can the Rio’s firmware be updated like the SlimX?
I see that there is a “caption editor” for the SlimX. What is that?
Any input or comments about other aspects of these units would be most welcome. Does anyone suggest other players? I'm interested in the best sound. That is most important to me.
Thanks
bj |
I've just gotten my SlimX so I'll update you on what I am aware of.
(1) SlimX is a great player and is very versatile. It can play mp3's(duh!), ACC, WMA but they plan to support other formats such as Ogg Vorbis etc. which is a much superior format to mp3 and i believe it could be the future. Supports various formats such as CDDA, Joliet, Romeo, Packet Write, ISO9660 etc.. Also it has powerful 12mW headphone out wihich is GREAT
. Battery life is decent
but UPDATE your firmware to get the benefits.
(2) Yes! There is hiss present thru the headphone out...but it is very prominent with low impedance phones such as the Etymotic ER-4P...frankly with time it didn't bother me so much but I would SO much prefer the hiss to not be there. Also the "BEEP" sound it makes whenever you do anything with the player drives me nuts with the 4P but most people aren't bugged by it.
With an amp thru the line out there is almost no hiss present so an amp would a good purchase for it.
You could try increasing the impedance of the ER-4P by purchasing an adapter from fixup. (someone paste his url here pls
)
(3) Build quality: This deservers a mention as it is amazing compared to other mp3 CD players
(4) Sound qualitywise it makes me want to sell my standalone Redbook CD Player the panasonic SL-CT780 but the hiss on the SlimX makes me keep it for those days when I want things perfect. But then again I have an amp so might just sell the 780.
In direct comparision to sound quality...the 780 is better but not by too much...I wouldnt mind a tradeoff as the SlimX is capable of reading multiple formats etc..
(5) Yes the SlimX supports playlists just use Winamp to make a .m3u file and burn it on your CD. (add "tada" sound here
)
(6) I dunno what the caption editor is but I guess it;s to change the iRiver names that pops up on the LCD when you start the player.
(7) Firmware updateable? Yes it is possible.
I have had the Rio you mentioned but it sound much MUCH worse to the SlimX. Yes its firmware is updateable but Rio doesn't update its firmware as frequently as iRiver which is one of the reasons I bought the SlimX.
I have no idea about the NexII but I suggest the SlimX is a great choice and you'll love it to death (just ask me how much I love it
).
Now you are suggesting you want the best possible sound...in that case a standalone portable cd player would be a better choice such as the Panasonic SL-CT780 as the sound quality is near perfect IMO. But the SlimX is quite close if the hiss and "BEEP" was eliminated.
So for the BEST sound get a good standalone cd player such as the Panasonic SL-CT780 but iif you want more of a balance and versatility get the SlimX and you can listen to both Redbook CD's or carry a ton of music on a CD for those long trips.
Hint: I use my SlimX much more than the Panasonic SL-CT780
Hope this helps