Quote:
Originally Posted by Laokid18 /img/forum/go_quote.gif
for me Joe Strummer.
|
I loved the Clash, and have posted extensively about my experiences of them live. They were great. He was great (Especially
Earthquake Weather.)
But come on! The most influential musician of all time? That seems excessive to me. I remember hearing and reading interviews in which he seemed more interested in discussing the musicians who had influenced
him, rather than holding forth on his own importance.
I think this thread, while interesting, poses an essentially unanswerable question. How does one make an apples-to-apples comparison among geniuses like Bob Marley, J.S. Bach, Bob Dylan, Fela Kuti, Duke Ellington, Hank Williams, Arnold Shoenberg, and Aretha Franklin? I don't really think it can be done, and the above is just a very short list of the possible candidates.
Perhaps it would be possible to list the members of a top tier, but I would have trouble limiting that list to 50 names. Never mind just one.
We all have our personal favorites, no doubt, but I think the universe of great music is too rich and varied to allow for the designation of a single "most influential" musician of all time.
But it has certainly been interesting to see the names that have come up in the course of this thread.