I have been wondering why we do not have the best sounding tubes for the LP in some kind of ranked order somewhere. After all, it has been nearly a year and a half since the LP was released, and after so many months discussing tube rolling options, one would normally expect there to be some kind of consensus about, at the very least, the top five types of tubes that sound best with the LP, especially since we are all using the same amp. In my case, I have mostly gone by random individual recommendations, amassing a whole set of tubes, some of which I have never even used before.
To be frank, some of those I have tested on my LP have not sounded as awesome as I expected them to be by following the recommendation of others, but that is not too surprising, since my chain of components is different from those of the recommenders. Still I have also received some recommendations that turned out to be really awesome (Reflektor Holy Grail '75 6N23P SWGP Silver Shields, and some pre-1960 Telefunkens: 1957-1959 - Gold pins, Gold rods, Fat O Getter) and that's how I identified what I consider to be the two best sounding sets of tubes that I keep rotating on my LP.
I am far from claiming that those are the two best sounding tubes for the LP anywhere. In fact, I am not sure that they are the two best sounding types among those I have amassed in the past year, as I have not had the time to test many sets that were recommended to me by others in any thorough way. The mentioned Reflektors and Telefunkens were just the first two I auditioned that seemed to get most things right, as compared to the stock tubes that came with the LP, and the gold lions which were the first replacement tubes I bought. I have mostly been too busy listening to the Reflector Holy grails and the Telefunkens during the little leisure time I have to tinker with other sets and audition them. As far as I am concerned, everything remains to be determined.
I still think it would be helpful if we had some kind of consensus about the top 5 or top 10 best sounding Liquid Platinum tubes (however provisional the ranking might be), which could serve as some kind of rough guide for new owners, and even old owners alike. I know that there are variables in subjective preferences and all that, but there are also variables when it comes to preferences in amps, and that has not prevented most of us from settling on the consensus about how awesome-sounding the LP itself is at its price point, when compared with other amps. I would personally create some kind of forum for that ranking of LP tubes, if I was as knowledgeable on the subject of tubes as some other posters on this forum are, or appear to be. However, I started experimenting with tubes only when I purchased the LP, and do not consider myself much of an expert on the subject, alas.