Miles Ahead: Stereo or not stereo?

Feb 8, 2003 at 8:38 AM Thread Starter Post #1 of 5

Eagle_Driver

Headphoneus Supremus
Joined
Jun 22, 2001
Posts
6,499
Likes
65
I recently bought a Columbia/Legacy 20-bit remaster of Miles Ahead. That was a 1957 recording of the Miles Davis/Gil Evans joint-band debut album. But when I listened to that CD, it was (and is) in TRUE STEREO!!
eek.gif
That's odd, since all vinyl editions and earlier CD editions of that album had been in either mono or 'fake stereo' (also called 'pseudo-stereo').

Now I found out the mystery of all that: Columbia Records studios had begun using two-track tape in 1957 - and it was in May of 1957 that Miles Ahead was recorded.

Anyone else find something odd about Miles Ahead?

Randy
eek.gif
eek.gif
eek.gif
 
Feb 9, 2003 at 12:37 AM Post #2 of 5
Randy,

I have the Miles Ahead sessions on both CD and reissued vinyl. Each are in magnificent "mono" as originally recorded.

I'm not sure which recordings you have.

confused.gif
 
Feb 9, 2003 at 6:07 AM Post #3 of 5
I actually have the 1997 Columbia/Legacy reissue on CD (CK 65121). It wasn't really recorded in mono - it was (originally) recorded on two-track tape (presumably to facilitate a better mixdown to mono). The reissue producer(s) of that currently available edition had decided to leave the two tracks "unadulterated" when they transferred the recording to CD; thus, it plays in "true stereo" (even though the package doesn't say so).
 
Feb 10, 2003 at 10:41 PM Post #4 of 5
The version I have is part of the "Miles Davis and Gill Evans Complete Columbia Studio Recordings". In the book that came with it they explain the stereo vs non-stereo issues around "Miles Ahead". The original sessions were done in May of '57 done on two track (best I can decipher from the writing, which is not super clear). During those sessions, Miles skipped several solos during 4 songs, "Springsville", "Miles Ahead", "New Rhumba" and "I Don't Wanna Be Kissed". Miles returned to the studio on August 22nd to do those solos. They had a three track for that session. Unfortunately, instead of having the earlier master on two tracks and Miles' overdub on the third track, they had the edited earlier takes in mono on one track, Miles overdub on the second and a combined mono mix created in realtime on the third track. To complicate things, apparently the mono recording that Miles was playing to in the overdub session did not play at precisely the same speed as the stereo two track, causing it to be out of sync with the stereo track. This mandated that these 4 songs had to be in mono, at least at that time.

The original issue was in mono.

A re-issue was done in 1987 in stereo. The technology wasn't good enough to overcome many of the obstacles and this issue wasn't very well though of. The 4 songs had to be "creatively" edited to make them stereo. This included different edits from the original issue using different takes made during the various recording sessions. Sometimes the overdubs were removed, other times they were creatively added. The non-overdubbed songs also had some different edits. These "altered" songs were not received well so Columbia pulled it and re-issued a mono version which was virtually the same as the original. A psuedo-stereo version is also mentioned but they don't give details other tha it was in '93.

As digital technology advanced, the sync problem between the overdubs and the original two track stereo could be solved. This lead to a true stereo version that held true to the original. I believe that this version was the '97 version.

The "Miles Davis and Gill Evans Complete Columbia Studio Recordings" is an excellent recording for Miles fans. It has "Miles Ahead" "Porgy And Bess" "Scetches of Spain" and "Quiet Nights". In addition it has tons of alternate takes, overdubs, and rehearsal sessions. For example, "Miles Ahead" spans almost two and a half CDs with all the different takes. In the booklet, it even has a breakdown of how the songs were edited and which takes were used where to create the songs. The CDs even use indexing to signal when edits take place in the songs. It's a really nice collection.
 
Feb 10, 2003 at 11:23 PM Post #5 of 5
Mystic-

I too have the Miles Davis and Gill Evans Complete Columbia Studio Recordings set and I agree that it's wonderful. I have several boxed sets of Miles' music, but I find myself listening to this collection most often.

smily_headphones1.gif
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top