The reason people go buy 1% or better resistors:
the high grade resistors aren't just more accurate, they are more stable too, ie. smaller temperature coefficent. When your amp heats up the temp changes, high grade R's will change less, this can be important to some circuits.
Also high grade resistors might have less thermocouple effects. A voltage can be generated when both ends of the resistor are not at the same temp, high grade metal films have lesser such effect than cheap carbon film stuff. The voltage (count as a DC offset), if at the input end, will be multiplied at the output. This might or might not be a problem, depending on how much DC offset is acceptable and how much temp difference the resistor's end sees. (this is one reason why vertical mounting of resistor is not recommanded in precision circuits -- the lower end will always be cooler than the top end).
I am not sure if hand matching lower grade resistors will have the above benefits associated with high grade metal film.......