You said you purchased the Gilmore Lite brand new? I remember reading in past threads about the GL that it really benefits from burn in and really starts to shine after several hours of operation. Maybe you should leave it running nonstop for about a week and see if your impressions change.
I just purchased a GL myself, and it does have the transparency and drive that everyone talks about. It is also dead silent with a totally black background compared to my Go-Vibe which has noticeable hiss when music isn't playing. However, the GL is a little light on bass so far. I don't want to spend the extra money for the upgraded PSU, so I'm hoping the bass response will improve with more burn in. I've been working for the past several days and have only gotten to listen to the amp for a couple of hours at most though, so perhaps I just need to grow accustomed to the new sound. At this point, there are some songs that I think sounded better through the Go-Vibe, but I'm sure that's because I had much more time to listen to it and was used to the way it presents the sound. Also, it may be that the GL is exposing all of the flaws in my MP3s...I'm sure the Go-Vibe isn't quite as revealing and transparent. I listened to Siamese Dream (FLAC) through the Go-Vibe yesterday morning after work and it was incredible!