I was reading this thread before getting a pair of R6i, and now I bought them, so thought I'd chip in with some first impressions.
I have owned S4 (broke - my fault), S4i (broke - not sure whose fault) and until recently S4i II (lost while drunk - definitely my fault). I'll compare them here to the S4i II's because those were the ones I was replacing and intended to buy, when I saw they were discontinued.
Build/design:
I much prefer the R6i to the S4(i) II for the following reasons:
- The cable is smooth! Halleluja! Not the rubbery/sticky texture from the S4i II-cable (owners will know what I'm talking about), which caught on to anything, and pulled your plugs out with even a slight brush against it. Also less cable noise. People complaining about cable noise from the R6(i) have clearly never owned S4(i) II's...
- They feel better in my ears, but that might have to to with the rubber tips being all new. Oddly, they almost feel lighter, even though they are 3,2 grams heavier according to specs.
- I was worried about the remote-control being on the left-side cable rather than in the middle. BUT on the R6i it seems much lighter than on the S4i II. I dont feel any pull whatsoever. Also the button layout is good. Only one button (play/pause), and for volume control the whole surface "tilts" up or down. For me that's brilliant, because I often couldn't tell the buttons from each other with out looking, because they only differed slightly in size.
- Strange detail, but due to the different design of the "house", I find these easier to fit in my ears. The flat area is the natural place to push with your finger.
- People who use the upside down/over the ear fitting with S4's be warned: These don't really fit this way. I haven't been able to find a sweet spot with good sound and a comfortable fit.
Sound:
I have only used these for 3 hours, hence they are not broken in. Also, I have a slight cold
Anyway, compared to the S4i II (which I found identical to the S4/S4i sound wise):
- Definitely more powerful bass. But tight, not boomy. I've tried boomy earbuds - these aren't boomy. Mids and highs are still there and are well defined. It's a w
armer sound, but also more gritty and insisting - slightly less "open" than the S4. I've noticed that the slightly more powerful lows give especially acoustic guitars and pianos a presence, that I sometimes missed with the S4s. Some techno and house tracks seem to benefit from it as well. My guess is that it's in the 2-300 Hz area, because it touches on lower mids. It's hard to describe, but It's like the R6's opens up extra "layers" of bass compared to the S4's, which had a deep, more controlled and pleasant, but also sightly less dynamic bass. However, I loved the crystal clarity of the S4's - even if a bit too crisp a times - and I do hope these will "open up" more after being broken in. But I can live with it if they dont.
- Output seems a bit lower with these. On both my iphone and Mac I listen to the R6i one or two volume "clicks" above what I'm used to with the S4's. Might change when broken in.
- These bleed more. They aren't loud as such and you probably won't annoy people on a bus/train/airplane (yes, ****ty-white-Apple-earbud guy/girl, I talking about you). But they are louder than the S4, which I could barely hear playing even at high volumes.
So there, my first impression. Hope you'll find it useful. I'll return with an update, if anything changes.
Cheers,
Andi