I’ve done a lot of recent a/b’ing of the FX700 and the W4 to try and determine which is ‘better’ for my tastes and thought I’d share my notes. All listening was done with a Nano 6g and digiZoid zo; Earsonics biflange tips on the W4 and UE tips on the FX700. So how did it go?
Radney Foster: Godspeed
W4- Intimate vocals; slightly muffled acoustic guitars when strummed hard; can’t hear Radney’s lips part and close like on FX700; sounds like a recording versus live; midrange presented more correctly than JVC’s; note edges are too soft, lacks crispness
FX700- Vocals sound further away; acoustic guitar sounds deeper and yet brighter but clearer; more realistic sounding acoustic guitar; I can hear more vocal detail of lips parting, more delicate vibrato; sounds live but not close to performer; has V shaped signature but not missing details; edges of notes are very crisp
Winner: FX700
Wallflowers: One Headlight
W4- Romantic presentation; drums lacking snap of FX700; subdued steel guitar; electric guitars are more upfront; bass line can get lost in presentation
FX700- Very snappy drums with impact; steel guitar sounds more realistic with brighter edge; bass line has better definition, easier to follow; lacks romantic presentation and intimate vocals; better dynamics that W4
Winner: FX700
Black Label Society: Southern Dissolution
W4- Big kick drum impact; crunchy, upfront electric guitars; forward vocals but guitars even more forward; minimal, non bothersome sibilance (song has recorded sibilance); good cymbal details; guitar lead takes center stage; big, wide soundstage
FX700 – Mids sound sucked out!; more noticeable sibilance; less crunch on guitars; not as wide of a soundstage; sounds busier, less instrument separation, drums are harder to pin point; cymbals are somehow splashier but get lost in presentation; kicks go deeper than W4; lead less upfront, not presented accurately in depth of soundstage
Winner: W4
Iron Maiden: Can I Play with Madness
W4- great instrument separation and drum detail; wide soundstage; bass line can get lost in presentation; vocals upfront and center
FX700- good but not great instrument separation (more organic sounding), slightly less drum detail; wide soundstage; more prominent bass line; guitars are not as upfront as W4
Winner: W4
Van Halen: Everybody Wants Some!
W4- Wide soundstage; nice crunch to Eddie’s guitars; great detail on drums; bass guitar doesn’t sounds as deep as it should harder to follow than FX700 but plenty of texture; Dave’s vocals are front and center; sounds a good deal closer to stage than FX700
FX700- Wide soundstage but maybe just a little smaller than W4; good crunch to guitars but a little further back in presentation; bass guitar sounds deep and textured, easy to follow, better presented than W4; drums aren’t as detailed; Dave sounds further way than on W4; sounds like I’m 20 rows or so back in audience
Winner: W4
Styx: Queen of Spades
W4- Wide and deep soundstage for intro; excellent separation and details; vocals upfront and center; backing vocals sound behind and to the sides of lead vocals as they should; lead guitar upfront; very realistic drums and can clearly hear every run; ending bass line has good texture but not dynamic like FX700
FX700- Opening guitars sound brighter more accurate; vocals further away but more detail, can hear individual breaths; slightly smaller soundstage in width but just as deep as W4; bass guitar sounds excellent in texture, placement and volume; drums not as defined as W4, less separation and runs sound more blended; this is the most upfront the guitars and vocals have been for the FX700 in this comparison, on par with W4; more dynamic sounding presentation than W4; kicks sound deeper and more impact than W4; ending bass line is excellently textured, very deep and engaging
Winner: Tie
Acoustic Guitar – FX700
Bass Guitar – FX700
Electric Guitar – W4
Steel Guitar – FX700
Vocals – TIE (presented in placement better with W4 but better detail with FX700)
Drums – W4 (better separation and detail with W4 but kicks sound better/deeper with FX700)
Soundstage – W4
No real winner here. Each have their strengths and weaknesses but overall are pretty equally matched.
Edit: After more listening for enjoyment and not comparing, I had forgotten how great the FX700's are for low volume listening. With that, they are the winners for me and it's time to sell the W4's.