Quote:
Originally Posted by Spyro /img/forum/go_quote.gif
Huh? W3 has perhaps the most V-shaped frequency response of any iem ever made. Even Westone themselves admit is a "fun" IEM meant for personal listening not monitoring or neutral-ness. Triple Fi is one of the most balanced which is why many find them somewhat boring. Even SE530 is far more balanced than W3.
|
To each their own. Now, I didn't say that Westone 3 is neutral, I just said that it's more balanced. With Triple.fi, I heard some crossover overlapping issues in upper bass, low mids, just like HeadphoneAddict once mentioned. With some music, the bass sounded as though it was "running over" the mids and that was a real big turn off for me. I also thought that Triple.fi's mids, while not recessed, sounded quite blurry, undefined, and just sounded as though there was some barrier between me and many instruments, singers - sort of like looking through a window, covered by some water vapor, if you know what I mean. Of course, maybe I just didn't get a good fit or needed to use a better source/amp to reveal Triple.fi's true potential, who knows? What really matters is that Westone 3 sounds better to me with my sources/amp than Triple.fi and I can't hear any problems with them that I just described hearing with Triple.fi. Westones sound completely coherent to my ears, like a single driver IEM - can't hear no weired overlaps whatsoever. Also, I think that with Westone 3, no part of the spectrum is overly emphasized or recessed - the bass and highs are somewhat bumped, sure, but not enough to ruin the presentation and what artist intended the listener to hear with good recordings. They just add some unique, but pleasant character of their own to the sound IMO. Now, that's what I mean by balance.
EDIT: To avoid confusion, I wan to clarify that for me balanced doesn't necessarily mean have to mean neutral, although I guess it can't be the other way around. If a headphone is neutral, then can it be unbalanced? Hmm... I guess that depends on which source/amp you're using and how balanced the 'phone is in characteristics other than frequency response. That is, for example, is a headphone has flat response, but lacks detail resolution, than it can't really be called completely balanced I guess. Westone 3 sounds good for me in every regard - it's got good soundstage, imaging, detail, no offensive peaks in frequency response, so I find it balanced. In other words, I guess a headphones has to be a good all-arounder in order to be called balanced.