Aeromarine
Head-Fier
- Joined
- Dec 18, 2016
- Posts
- 63
- Likes
- 13
have you ever had chance hear noble savanna? what do you think about the sound? is it better with a DAC?
have you ever had chance hear noble savanna? what do you think about the sound? is it better with a DAC?
I couldn't resist.
S-EM9 and Velvet has the same bass driver and bass driver configuration. Exactly the same. The only difference is, on Velvet you can adjust the bass resistor. You gave S-EM9, 9/10 and Velvet, 6/10 for bass. I've auditioned both of them and their basses are very similar and they're also very nice.
I couldn't resist.
S-EM9 and Velvet has the same bass driver and bass driver configuration. Exactly the same. The only difference is, on Velvet you can adjust the bass resistor. You gave S-EM9, 9/10 and Velvet, 6/10 for bass. I've auditioned both of them and their basses are very similar and they're also very nice.
So let me get this straight.
Do you think that we should give Velvet's bass a straight 9, because it's the exact same driver? Well maybe if we could ignore that it has NO MIDBASS whatsoever?... Maybe, but that's unfortunately not the case. Midbass is naturally a part of the bass section, so that's why it gets a 6. An IEM with having almost zero midbass can not get above 6 in my book. I understand that's also a reason for many people to favor it but the table should be more objective than that.
Btw, I'm not sure it's the same driver. The bass sounds really complete and miles better on S-EM9. Even if it's the same driver and same configuration (how you could be so sure is a mystery to me), that doesn't mean it should sound the same or on same success level because there's a thing called synergy with other drivers.
Anyway, that's my ranking so you don't have to agree.
I might get a Velvet V2 in the near future for a review, I hope it's more coherent this time. (like what ES-3 is able do to)
They have the same driver number.
This is the problem about your list. Remember the last time I wrote? It was about something similar. Concepts. When you put a bass section on your IEM list, I assume it was something about the bass quality which Velvet has a great one. When you put -if you look at our last discussion- things called "tonality", "control" people tend to understand something different.
I'm not saying you're wrong. True, Velvet has a dip at the mid-bass. (whereas the lack of mid-bass on Velvet affects the mids more than basses) I'm saying the list is incomplete. If you put a legend(key map) it can be more accurate. Look, I'm making a constructive criticism.
Thanks for the chart.
How do you compare, and which do you think is better, Campfire Andromeda or Oriolus? Especially in the female vocals aspect