HIFIMAN Sundara Review
The first few days after receiving the Sundara, I just casually listened to it whenever I had the time. Straight out of my phone (Asus Zenfone AR) they got loud enough on the highest volume setting and sounded good for the most part. But the highs were a lot more pronounced and impactful than the rest, resulting in an unbalanced and bright impression that I found tinny and unpleasant. That didn't change much with the iFi nano iDSD.
I was fortunate enough to have just won an iFi micro iDSD, and this changed the story somewhat. I had my first really enjoyable listening session with the Sundara driven by the micro iDSD, with my phone as the source. The good DAC and powerful amp of the micro iDSD certainly helped, but the real key was the XBass switch on the iDSD, increasing the low end just a hair to be satisfying at a volume that didn't make the highs overwhelming. Nice! As I found out later, XBass works best for mostly electronic music or pop, as it makes instruments sound less real. I wish I had a Schiit Loki to try, though this wouldn't work with a DAC/amp combo.
I do tend to get used to somewhat bass shy headphones a few minutes after starting a listening session, and the Sundara is no exception. It has clean and well extended bass with decent amps, but a bit more would be needed for a more primal type of enjoyment in my case. I felt similarly about the Sennheiser HD800 the few times I tried it, though based on memory the Sundara has the better bass extension.
Finally, I did a more thorough listening session, comparing the $499 HIFIMAN Sundara to the Philips SHP9500S that I got for $57, and my favourite pair of open headphones, the $1799 MrSpeakers Ether Flow.
Computer: Microsoft Surface Pro 4
Software: foobar2000 using ASIO
USB cable: USB 3.0 extension cable supplied with iFi micro iDSD
DAC: iFi micro iDSD, USB powered, Turbo mode, standard filter, polarity +, direct out, 3D off
Interconnects: Schiit PYST RCA, 6"
Amps:
- Schiit Jotunheim, high gain, 6.35mm out (all headphones)
- iFi micro iDSD, IEMatch off, XBass as noted (Sundara only)
Power cable: Tripp-Lite Heavy Duty 14 AWG, 12ft
Power conditioning: iFi iPurifier AC (for Jotunheim only)
Headphones:
- Philips SHP9500S with 1/8" thick Neoprene rubber rings under the earpad padding, Kabeldirekt 6ft aux cable + 3.5mm to 6.35mm adapter.
- HIFIMAN Sundara with stock 5ft cable + stock 3.5mm to 6.35mm adapter
- MrSpeakers Ether Flow with 6ft DUM cable, 6.35mm plug
At some point I stopped also using the micro iDSD as an amp since the XBass feature has its downsides, and otherwise the sound was very similar to the Jotunheim, maybe with slightly more pronounced mids.
The Bucky Pizzarelli Trio - Three For All (FLAC 24/192)
Jot + SHP9500S: Good detail, good transients, a bit bright, slightly harsh, lacking low end. Sound stage fair. Engaging.
Jot + Sundara: Fuller midrange, more relaxed and thus relaxing, seems slower (driver speed), less detailed. Deeper sound stage. Engaging. Song seems slowed down.
Jot + Ether Flow: Low end more present, still relaxed, very resolving. Sound stage fair. Engaging. Don't want to stop.
iFi + Sundara: More satisfying low end (XBass), mids more present, higher noise floor
Alison Wonderland - Awake (FLAC 16/44)
Jot + SHP9500S: A bit hollow, bass lacking in quantity, muddy, a bit harsh, missing definition in the highs
Jot + Sundara: Vocals more pleasant, more bass, well defined bass, somewhat punchy, clear highs, engaging
iFi + Sundara: (With XBass) Strong bass, a bit wooly
Jot + Ether Flow: Good bass presence, a bit too bright / sharp highs
Alexis Cole - Whippoorwill (FLAC 24/192)
Jot + SHP9500S: Lacking bass, flat percussions, tinny, unpleasant noise floor, voice nasal, unengaging, okay cymbals, but too present
Jot + Sundara: Much more balanced, natural sounding, pleasant, good detail, nice sound stage, bass a tad too quiet, engaging
iFi + Sundara: Percussions sound a bit off with XBass on (initial thud a bit too strong, less decay), noise more noticeable with XBass
Jot + Ether Flow: Lovely decay, very smooth, detailed. Don't want to stop listening.
Deftones - Prince (FLAC 24/96)
Jot + SHP9500S: Too bright, a bit harsh, drums not punchy enough, bass is nice, cymbals not convincing, voice getting drowned out, sounds busy
Jot + Sundara: Bass has more grunt, cymbals not convincing, drums more impactful, no problem focusing on voice. Sounds okay.
iFi + Sundara: Meaty bass, drums a bit off again, without XBass closer to Jot, but still less punchy
Jot + Ether Flow: Meaty bass, drums a bit off (apparently the recording), cymbals pleasant, nice grunt in the bass, seem to have an easier time keeping up with the music, making it easier to listen to, punchy, engaging
Sarah Jarosz - Green Lights (FLAC 24/96)
Jot + SHP9500S: Seemed a bit weak at first, but got used to it. Highs a bit too shrill, mids lacking. Bass could be better defined. But quite listenable, nice guitars. Engaging.
Jot + Sundara: Cleaner, more resolving, nice vocals, good bass impact, definitely engaging. Enjoyable sound stage. Don't want to stop listening.
iFi + Sundara: Bass seems somewhat forced and artificial (XBass), fine without XBass. Mids more present.
Jot + Ether Flow: More resolving, noticeable in guitars and voice, bass a bit stronger than Sundara with good impact and texture. A bit closed in. Engaging, but a bit overpowering.
Marian Hill - Talk to Me (FLAC 24/44)
Jot + SHP9500S: Tinny, too bright, not enough bass, vocals sound recessed, like too far away from the mic. Fatiguing.
Jot + Sundara: Above issues gone, and clearer. Bass still somewhat lacking, but well extended. Engaging. Fun.
iFi + Sundara: Thank you, XBass. Happy to keep listening.
Jot + Ether Flow: Tight. Punchy. Effortless.
Candido Camero - Wa Wa Wa (FLAC 24/192)
Jot + SHP9500S: Nice guitars. Engaging. Good drums. Recessed vocals, a bit hollow sounding. Good sound stage. Don't want to stop listening.
Jot + Sundara: More resolving. Nice trumpets. Better imaging. Punchier. Vocals still recessed. Sound stage deeper. Want to keep listening.
Jot + Ether Flow: Even more resolving. More impact. Trumpets a bit harsh before lowering the volume a bit (Ethers need less volume to be satisfying). Vocals still recessed (recording). Sound stage less deep, makes it a bit less fun. Sucked into recording.
Sia - Numb (MP3 from Amazon.com)
Jot + SHP9500S: Bright. Harsh. Tinny. Lacks bass. Hollow.
Jot + Sundara: Balanced sound. Nice vocals. Resolving. Bass is good, but could be a bit stronger. Want to keep listening.
iFi + Sundara: Bass amount is better with XBass, but sounds more artificial and less tight. More pleasant without XBass.
Jot + Ether Flow: Mmmmh, that voice. Bass is fuller, more visceral and defined. Beautiful sound.
Cécile McLorin Salvant - If A Girl Isn’t Pretty (FLAC 24/96)
Jot + SHP9500S: Sounds a bit artificial. Bass is pretty good here. Voice sounds tinny. Cymbals a bit too bright. Piano grainy. All in all still listenable, though.
Jot + Sundara: Sound stage! Everything sounds more natural. There's more detail.
Jot + Ether Flow: Lovely voice. Bass has bite. Sound stage not as deep. Cymbals are very nice. Drums are textured.
Miley Cyrus - Someone Else (MP3 from Amazon.com)
Jot + SHP9500S: Voice sounds a bit tinny. Too bright. Bass could be stronger. The usual. But you get used to it and then it's still fun.
Jot + Sundara: Much more balanced sound, clean bass. Transients! Didn't notice them with the Philips.
Jot + Ether Flow: Deep, tight bass, well extended, slow roll off. Great transients. Punchy. Engaging.
Nils Lofgren - Keith Don't Go (FLAC 16/44)
Jot + SHP9500S: Sounds a bit artificial. Somewhat harsh. Thin voice. Clapping sounds artificial. Simply seems to skip the faster transients that I know are in there, instead of smearing them, which is good.
Jot + Sundara: Fuller sound due to better bass, more resolving. Clapping sounds natural.
Jot + Ether Flow: You could drown in that decay. While even the Philips make the guitar sound fast, there's texture and nuance even in the short transients here that's missing with the other two cans. Quite captivating. Want to keep listening.
Black String - Mask Dance (FLAC 24/96)
Jot + SHP9500S: Surprisingly good. Somewhat recessed mids. Becomes a bit incoherent during busier passages.
Jot + Sundara: More visceral. More natural. Expansive sound stage. Better imaging, more textured. So much to listen for!
Jot + Ether Flow: In the beginning, there's an interesting sound in the background that gave a much more plausible sense of space on the Sundara. Otherwise similar, just a bit more resolving and with more, textured bass. The diminished sound stage here makes the busier sections overwhelming.
Sia - Rewrite (MP3 from Amazon)
Jot + SHP9500S: Exaggerated highs, underwhelming bass, lack of details. Might sound fine if you don't know better.
Jot + Sundara: This is much more more like it. Silky smooth bass, nice vocals.
Jot + Ether Flow: Similar to Sundara, a bit brighter, a bit more bass.
Design, comfort, etc.
The Sundara is a good looking pair of headphones! It feels lighter than the Ether Flow. It is a bit less comfortable than the SHP9500S due to the pads touching my ears in few places, and the clamping force. I found that pushing the earcups forward decreased the clamping force to acceptable levels even for longer sessions. The HIFIMAN Edition X V2 with its cavernous ear cups is on a different level, but the Sundara's sound stage sounds more natural to me. Instead of sounding spacious, the music merely seems to come from further away with the Edition X V2. There is barely any damping of background noise, similar to the SHP9500S. The Ether Flow in contrast muffles even your own voice, and seems more semi-open in that regard. For the most part, the build quality seems great. However, the disks at the earcup hinges were already showing some wear and tear, as did the inner notches for the headband adjustment levels. Best to always use a headphone stand instead of putting them on a table. I did not enjoy the angled plug. While it certainly seemed robust, the cable often pulled the plug into an inconvenient orientation or got in the way of the volume knob. I also noticed a chemical smell from the earpads the first two days, but didn't notice it anymore later (unlike the AR-H1).
Conclusion
If you have a capable amp, and prefer moderate bass or have tone controls that don't ruin the music you like listening to, the Sundara is a great pair of headphones at $499. It offers clean, clear and fairly resolving sound with good extension, and a lovely sound stage. It's a bit light in the bass and fatiguing when power starved. When driven properly, it is vastly superior to the SHP9500S, and it should be given the price. The HD800 still has an even better sound stage, and the Ether Flow is more resolving. I did not enjoy the mids of the ÆON Flow Open, but its bass was more satisfying than the Sundara's, while not as far extended. Of course, these three options are also more expensive.
Thanks a lot to @Todd for the opportunity!