Headphones vs Speakers -- an Inconvenient Truth
post-13173975
Thread Starter
Post #1 of 350

GuyUnder

AKA GUTB, mdavid
Joined
Dec 19, 2016
Messages
89
Reaction score
17
Joined
Dec 19, 2016
Posts
89
Likes
17
Most people say that after a certain point, high end headphones stop making sense and money is better spent on speakers.

But the hard truth to face is -- speakers aren't nearly as resolving as high end headphones, and getting than the center image from loudspeakers takes an optimal room geometry that most people don't have. My speakers sound like veiled trash next to my HE-6, TH900 and Utopia.
 
post-13174011
Post #2 of 350

Mr Rick

Headphoneus Supremus
Joined
Jan 24, 2015
Messages
2,576
Reaction score
825
Location
Costa Mesa, Ca
Joined
Jan 24, 2015
Location
Costa Mesa, Ca
Posts
2,576
Likes
825
Thank you for your opinion.

 
     Share This Post       
post-13174427
Post #3 of 350

ProtegeManiac

Headphoneus Supremus
Joined
Oct 29, 2009
Messages
15,878
Reaction score
2,800
Location
Manila
Joined
Oct 29, 2009
Location
Manila
Posts
15,878
Likes
2,800
Website
www.instagram.com
Most people say that after a certain point, high end headphones stop making sense and money is better spent on speakers.

But the hard truth to face is -- speakers aren't nearly as resolving as high end headphones, and getting than the center image from loudspeakers takes an optimal room geometry that most people don't have. My speakers sound like veiled trash next to my HE-6, TH900 and Utopia.
 
Well the thing is some people do neglect to take into account that the money on an expensive headphone system could have been spent on acoustic treatments so their speakers don't sound like veiled trash or have a weird soundstage. I didn't start really getting into headphones until I spent a little bit on acoustic panels that didn't fix the skewed image in my room.
 
post-13174820
Post #4 of 350

GuyUnder

AKA GUTB, mdavid
Joined
Dec 19, 2016
Messages
89
Reaction score
17
Joined
Dec 19, 2016
Posts
89
Likes
17
Well I've spent over $500 on carpeting and acoustic panels. My entire living room was made into a listening room.

I got a pair of those new Chane 1.4s (bookshelves) and a Teac integrated (which claims to use an ICEPower amp so it shouldn't be garbage) to power them.

Veiled, rolled off, BORING, unresolving. It's true that the soundstage is wide, but it's basically center, left and right.

It's like, I'm listening to THIS instead of my Utopias?

So what's going on? Are my speakers just entry level junk and I'm being taught a lesson for listening to avsforum?
 
     Share This Post       
post-13174848
Post #5 of 350

Music Alchemist

Pokémon trainer of headphones
Joined
Dec 17, 2013
Messages
19,810
Reaction score
1,824
Joined
Dec 17, 2013
Posts
19,810
Likes
1,824
Even if I heard a speaker system that was better than headphone systems in every way, I would still prefer the intimate presentation of headphones. I favor feeling at one with the music rather than having it come at me from a distance.
Edit: Since April 2017, I prefer speakers over headphones.

I think it's funny when people talk about headphones having giant soundstages. An HD 800 is on my head right now and it sounds pretty intimate to me—just the way I like it. (Even cheap desktop speakers are far more spacious.)

Some interesting articles:
http://www.innerfidelity.com/content/strengths-and-weaknesses-headphones-and-speakers
http://www.innerfidelity.com/content/across-great-divide-can-we-love-headphones-speakers-equally
http://www.innerfidelity.com/content/aes-headphone-technology-conference-highlight-paper

Imaging - Here's one I didn't know: Turns out that while headphone imaging is inside the head, it has been found to be more precise than speakers. In the plot above, speakers at 3 meters (normal room listening), speakers at 1 meter (near field listening), and headphones were evaluated for the ability to precisely locate a sound within the normal stereo image.
 
Last edited:
     Share This Post       
  • Like
Reactions: dmdm and GasMaskMan
post-13175104
Post #6 of 350

Bazile

100+ Head-Fier
Joined
Feb 5, 2007
Messages
274
Reaction score
95
Joined
Feb 5, 2007
Posts
274
Likes
95
Most people say that after a certain point, high end headphones stop making sense and money is better spent on speakers
 
Sir;
I'm not convinced that most people really say that. I think that "most people" on this site agree that headphone and speaker imaging differ. I also agree that folks will prefer one or the other. But "after a certain point" one is better than the other...nonsense Sir. 
 
     Share This Post       
  • Like
Reactions: canali
post-13175168
Post #7 of 350

ProtegeManiac

Headphoneus Supremus
Joined
Oct 29, 2009
Messages
15,878
Reaction score
2,800
Location
Manila
Joined
Oct 29, 2009
Location
Manila
Posts
15,878
Likes
2,800
Website
www.instagram.com
Well I've spent over $500 on carpeting and acoustic panels. My entire living room was made into a listening room.

I got a pair of those new Chane 1.4s (bookshelves) and a Teac integrated (which claims to use an ICEPower amp so it shouldn't be garbage) to power them.

Veiled, rolled off, BORING, unresolving. It's true that the soundstage is wide, but it's basically center, left and right.

It's like, I'm listening to THIS instead of my Utopias?

So what's going on? Are my speakers just entry level junk and I'm being taught a lesson for listening to avsforum?
 
The problem with speakers is that you have an entire room that can affect the sound whereas headphones are just right there by your ear canals. That makes it easier for a headphone to be more resolving since the room barely affects it past ambient noise. On the flipside, your left ear can't hear the right driver and vice versa, so imaging even on an HD800 can have issues. In some cases it's not even higher resolution but that you have some mild peaks (but peaks nonetheless) on the treble response that enhances what you perceive to be detail. Look at how headphones known to be "detailed" have such peaks while anything with a relatively flat though relatively weaker output (vs 1000hz and below) are known to be "laid back." Case in point: K701 vs HD650.
 
If you speakers sound like a headphone, ie, strong L-C-R with nothing in-between, that's as likely a problem with the room as the speakers. For starters, that kind of problem primarily lies in toe-in angles, and then on the room. Depending on the dispersion patter, too much toe in means narrow soundstage; too little, and you have a very 2D image with strong output on the flanks and center.  And what works with your seat 1.5m away won't necessarily work from 3m away.
 
Also, having tried some treatments doesn't automatically mean the speaker sucks, let alone all speakers suck, but of course there comes a point where treatments essentially will be like rebuilding the room altogether and the downsides of headphones are a good compromise compared to the time and money involved (let alone if you can even do such extensive work on the room).
 
     Share This Post       
  • Like
Reactions: dmdm
post-13179159
Post #10 of 350

oatp1b1

Head-Fier
Joined
Jun 25, 2014
Messages
96
Reaction score
24
Joined
Jun 25, 2014
Posts
96
Likes
24
Well I've spent over $500 on carpeting and acoustic panels. My entire living room was made into a listening room.

I got a pair of those new Chane 1.4s (bookshelves) and a Teac integrated (which claims to use an ICEPower amp so it shouldn't be garbage) to power them.

Veiled, rolled off, BORING, unresolving. It's true that the soundstage is wide, but it's basically center, left and right.

It's like, I'm listening to THIS instead of my Utopias?

So what's going on? Are my speakers just entry level junk and I'm being taught a lesson for listening to avsforum?
I know you're likely baiting, but you cannot really compare a set of 400 dollar speakers with a pair of 4000 dollar headphones and anticipate them to be as good.
 
     Share This Post       
post-13180017
Post #11 of 350

Rainstar

Head-Fier
Joined
Oct 21, 2012
Messages
50
Reaction score
18
Location
San Jose California
Joined
Oct 21, 2012
Location
San Jose California
Posts
50
Likes
18
I use a $6000 integrated amp, I own most of the decent high end headphones. My speakers are preety good $10,000 msrp. I like some songs better on the headphones. Speakers > headphones. I blast speakers when no one is home and headphones when there are people. If I had to start all over I would go with speakers first.
 
     Share This Post       
  • Like
Reactions: dmdm and Dawnrazor
post-13180318
Post #12 of 350

musikevan

Head-Fier
Joined
Jul 8, 2007
Messages
59
Reaction score
21
Joined
Jul 8, 2007
Posts
59
Likes
21
A carefully chosen, matched and properly positioned room-audio setup can be a thing of beauty. It will be less detailed and less neutral than headphones...but maybe more forgiving of most recordings. Nearly all headphones sound hyper detailed and too precise compared to a live acoustical performance of classical music. I find prices of a great headphone setup to be cheaper than a room based one, but not by that much. Room acoustics mods are free or dirt cheap. Decent inexpensive speakers are everywhere, cheap amps are common too.
 
     Share This Post       
  • Like
Reactions: dmdm and HAWX
post-13180322
Post #13 of 350

theveterans

Headphoneus Supremus
Joined
Sep 2, 2014
Messages
2,222
Reaction score
792
Location
Santa Rosa, Laguna, Philippines
Joined
Sep 2, 2014
Location
Santa Rosa, Laguna, Philippines
Posts
2,222
Likes
792
Age
29
Well I've spent over $500 on carpeting and acoustic panels. My entire living room was made into a listening room.

I got a pair of those new Chane 1.4s (bookshelves) and a Teac integrated (which claims to use an ICEPower amp so it shouldn't be garbage) to power them.

Veiled, rolled off, BORING, unresolving. It's true that the soundstage is wide, but it's basically center, left and right.

It's like, I'm listening to THIS instead of my Utopias?

So what's going on? Are my speakers just entry level junk and I'm being taught a lesson for listening to avsforum?
 
IMO you chose the wrong speakers. I chose the Yamaha HS7 as my bookshelf speaker due to their unveiled presentation, precise imaging and excellent resolution for the price. It's better sounding and resolving than my AKG K712 headphone. Seriously, if you have invested so much on headphones already, you need to match it with speaker setup just to be on Utopia's level. For example KEF Reference 1 when listened on a small living room should be able to keep up with Utopias in sound quality.
 
     Share This Post       
  • Like
Reactions: Agent of Chaos
post-13193921
Post #14 of 350

canali

Headphoneus Supremus
Joined
Jun 25, 2003
Messages
2,813
Reaction score
436
Joined
Jun 25, 2003
Posts
2,813
Likes
436
there is no inconvenient truth imo.
Hi to each their own.
 
a colleague i know feels headgear is subpar to a nice speaker setup.
he once had a US$70k system (his interconnects alone were $5k each)
..he preferred his beloved sonus faber speakers and wadia cd player and esoteric $20k japanese shindo tube amp.
but he also had to spend 2k on room treatments, too.
he's recently downsized 90% but still prefers 3d speaker sound.
he feels headgear can't compete on imaging, space etc.
in fact he only uses his cans (senn momentums) for late night listening
so as to not disturb his wife while sleeping.
(but give cans a few yrs: more tech is coming out to take that 'in our head' sound
to make it more speaker and 3d like).
 
i just got back into audio last yr...started off with head gear.
 
recently, however, I realized that i missed the larger, room filling music from speakers.  
eg., when cooking or cleaning up having some live music to add some joy and life to my apt
or while surfing at my desktop.
so i  started with a desktop setup near  my kitchen: got the audioengine a5+ and a pioneer sub
...love the live music that can now spill out around me.
now moving up to trying to find some focal alpha 50s to replace the audioengine a5+.
additionally I am now looking at the new kef ls50 wls speakers to start
setting up a home system in the living room.
 
but that said: i also love the fab resolution and bang for buck value that good headgear
can deliver, esp when i want to crank things up guilt free and not worry
about pissing off my neighbours....looking at the focal elear to replace or compliment my senn 650s
 
so in the end: different strokes for different folks...i love both, to be frank
which is ideally what many of us perfer...but in the end it's a matter of limited $$$.
 
     Share This Post       
  • Like
Reactions: HAWX
post-13197996
Post #15 of 350

5genez

100+ Head-Fier
Joined
Nov 12, 2015
Messages
488
Reaction score
140
Location
Georgia USA
Joined
Nov 12, 2015
Location
Georgia USA
Posts
488
Likes
140
Age
71
Well I've spent over $500 on carpeting and acoustic panels. My entire living room was made into a listening room.

I got a pair of those new Chane 1.4s (bookshelves) and a Teac integrated (which claims to use an ICEPower amp so it shouldn't be garbage) to power them.

Veiled, rolled off, BORING, unresolving. It's true that the soundstage is wide, but it's basically center, left and right.

It's like, I'm listening to THIS instead of my Utopias?

So what's going on? Are my speakers just entry level junk and I'm being taught a lesson for listening to avsforum?

 
 
 
Put one of these in the audio circuit and the veiling will be gone...https://www.amazon.com/BBE-Sound-482i-Sonic-Maximizer/dp/B0002FDKIW/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1485136499&sr=8-1&keywords=482i+sonic+maximizer   
 
 
.... Tweak the bottom end until it sounds balanced.  No need for a sub woofer if the speakers are of high enough quality in many cases...  and, I advise keeping off the high end process unless your speakers really need it.
 
The heart of this unit is the NJM2153 chip made by NJR Corporation. Its the same company that gave us the audiophile Muses 01 and 02 chips.  It was designed to counter the veiling effect found in speakers.   All you interconnects and cables will suddenly reveal their strengths, or weaknesses.  Why?  Transparency.
 
     Share This Post       
  • Like
Reactions: snellemin

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 1)

Top