Quote:
Originally Posted by Syzygies
I've heard this many times. Does silver actually test bright? Can anyone give an equivalent circuit for silver wire, explaining why it is bright? Or is this all in the departure from linearity? There must have been explanations offered for this, over the years...
|
I'm not going to jump into the silver versus copper debate because, quite frankly, I can't hear a difference. But there is a physical difference - if nothing else, the silver wire is a better conductor than copper, for a given wire thickness. You can model the circuit as a series of RLC elements whose values match the specified unit length values of whatever cable you're considering. Assuming two cables of identical geometry, the only thing that will change will be the resistive element. And as that resistance drops, the corner frequency of the cable (acting as a low pass filter) will increase.
But...
The cable isn't the Lone Ranger here. It interacts with the rest of the system. So, depending on the output impedance of the source and the input imedance of the load, the actual effects of the cable on the audio signal will differ.
Consider, for example, a source with low output impedance and a load (say a headphone amplifier) with a high input impedance. As an example, Rout of 5 Ohms and Rin of 100 KOhms. A run of the mill copper cable might have as much as 1.5 Ohms of impedance across its length. Put that in series with 100 KOhms and...well...you can lower that cable's impedance and pretty much not do anything to the signal.
Even on the headphone side, Rload is still typically one or two orders of magnitude greater than the resistance of the cable. So, at least theoretically, I have a tough time with the idea that two cables of identical geometry, but made of copper or silver, are going to sound different. I can say that, by my ears, they don't...and that's my only conclusion.
-Drew