Well, you can sample some of the music I listen to right here:
I trust you may find some ecletism in there...
So, when people who love music search for headphones, and they want something practical like a pair of true wireless earbuds, they want them to sound good with Radiohead and Miles Davis and Kendrick Lamar and Tame Impala and Idles and... whatever you want to throw at them.
Definitely, IMO, headphones shouldn’t be built or factory tuned for... these will be good for Bob Marley... these will be good for Daft Punk... these will be good for Billie Holiday...
A flat frequency response may seem less exciting at first, even the name - flat - but this is what should be intended, this is what the better brands try to look for (albeit keeping their “signature” in there). Linear is a better name.
Then, when you have a good, linear, trustworthy base, you can (and should be able to) customize them to “your” preference or to whatever genre of music where you might believe there’s tweaking to be done. Freedom is the key... your taste, your sound.
Sooooo this ^^^ This is ultimately my goal when searching for new headphones. If a company tunes a headphone to a bloated bass, and recessed mids, and veiled treble (let's say for example), it is usually done to cover up the technical issues that the drivers have, and therefore these cannot usually be tuned in a different direction (to suite your ears). In contrast a linearly tuned headphone will allow you to tune them to almost ANY way you like, because they are more likely to be able to technically handle ALL the frequencies correctly.
Bass is supposed to rumble and it is supposed to be felt. People who like a completely flat sound obviously have no clue what other genres are supposed to sound like. Hip hop with no impact in the background feels awkward to listen to.
By your statements alone, you are the one (in this case) who doesn't really have a clue. You are passing off opinion (and your personal opinion at that) as fact. You are misled by the headphone/speaker industry. By the way they tune some of the mainstream stuff, they are telling you JUST that. But, does it match what the artist intended? If you do some searching, you will see that there are very few recording artists that use headphones that have that bloated bass or veiled treble. They use studio monitors, which are tuned very linear, or flat. This is what it means when you see "how the artist intended", not what the headphone manufacturers TELL you is intended. This is a marketing ploy to get you to buy their product. You will see the terms "Fun", and "Analytical" around here. Fun are not accurate, but tend to sound good to certain types of listeners. Analytical is just that; accurate....
Who told you that bass is SUPPOSED to rumble or to be felt? In some stuff, I would agree, but I have also heard many a song that has more subtle bass (and was intended to be that way), and if you have a set of phones that have all bass, you will NOT be hearing it as was intended. I have headphones that can do both when the song calls for it. Also, rumble is not the same thing as impact at all when describing bass. I have some headphones that have no rumble at all, but have plenty of impact.
It sounds to me like your only genre is hip-hop (or at least the genres that focus on bass more than any other thing). I find it a bit offensive that you would say that people who like flat sound have no clue with other genres. To say that people have a distorted view of bass, and that they have no clue means to me that you think the world revolves around hip-hop, and there is no other genre worth listening to unless you are old. This is a biased view, and shows your ignorance (and age) about music in general.
The definition of an audiophile is:
Definition of audiophile
: a person who is enthusiastic about high-fidelity sound reproduction
This short definition alone implies accuracy, or the "way the artist intended". What you are arguing is there is no other genre worth listening to (or that the "type" of sound you like is the only one), and everyone else should agree with you. I respect your opinion (but only as an opinion, not as fact), let others have theirs (whether you agree or not). If you don't like the way people think on this community, find another one that is more to the line of thinking you are on.