I took a quick listen to it on AOL the other day and is it just me or do all foo fighter songs sound the same (which isn't a bad thing). I thought there were a couple of new twists/beats/riffs mixed into the bag but all and all, it sounded much like their other songs.
Its alright, i respect the pedigree of the band, nufan, nirvana, the germs, and especially sunny day real estate were bands i enjoyed back in the day, and i personally feel that everlong is one of the greatest songs of all time, but i generally feel that dave grohl is a boring songwriter and most foo songs just have the same sound. As does this album. Give it up for recording in analog though!