No headphone, or amp, or dac or cable is PERFECT. Why is that? Cause everyone's ears are different folks. Everyone's musical preferences are different, and finally everyone's brain is different. We like what we like and we move on from what we dislike. Lets just imagine that Tyll was a food critic instead of a HiFi reviewer for just a moment K? And today Tyll wrote a review that said he suddenly found that McDonald's newest burger that costs thousands of $ was a gastronomic delight and that all other food pales in comparison. Would you automatically step out to your local mickey D's and plunk down a couple of K's. Would you ask for a taste first? Would you add a pickle or lettuce or special sauce? Personally, that burger would have to be damn outstanding for me to spring a couple of K's on and i would CERTAINLY have to do a cautious taste test FIRST. Headphones are no different. To some they may be TOTL, they shine in every way possible to their taste. To others, they may need a little boost to be just right. Think not? Just look at those who mod headphones and the huge amount of money spent doing so. Still others may just rip them off their head and toss them against the wall in disgust.
How many bad reviews have you seen about the Sen 800S, 800's 700's, how about Audeze lcd 2, 3, and 4, the Beyer T series. How many times have the words like veiled, mushy, too bright, too loose, dull, flat and lifeless, boomy, bloated .... blah blah blah have you seen on other hp's? Does this mean that all of those TOTL or near TOTL HP's are a waste of money? To some yes, but to a majority of those who do enjoy them, they are their sweet spot.
TO ME, the elear just sounds RIGHT. It appeals to my ear, my music and my build quality taste. It does what it needs to do to make ME happy. We share our views on the equipment we enjoy and dislike on these forums because in most cases we WANT to help others make informed decisions. There is no concrete answer as to if the Elear is right or wrong for anyone. But, if anyone has any inclination at all about giving them a try, then I would certainly think it would be worth the effort to do so.