Disclaimer, these are the first IEMs I own and this is the fist review I write for an audio product.
Until now, my only experience with IEMs was a small listening session with the Fiio FH1 and the FA5. The in-ears I have listened to the most are the AKG buds that came with my Samsung S9 (which are surprisingly good actually)
I found the Fiio FD1 for sale on a local classifieds site, for the equivalent of 52Eur (59USD), which I thought is a very good deal and low enough price not to be sorry if they were broken, so I called up the seller. I was actually surprised to find out that they were practically new. The seller tried them with his own tips for 2-3 hours, did not like them and put them up for sale.
First impression, connected to a BTR5, with foam tips, using the unbalanced 3.5mm cable they came with: a bit to many highs (harsh, sometimes sibilant) in certain songs, but they have potential, so, I left them playing metal, electro, jazz, classic, at 50% volume out of the MusicBee / BTR5 for about 20 hours.
I know, I know, burn in snake oil, but what harm can it do?
Well, it seems It actually did good. Now, after listening to them for a few more hours with the foam tips on, they have definitely relaxed, but in certain songs they still sound a bit harsh (Pendulum's Immersion album for example, but this might be because of the mastering as well). In most of the music I listen to (metal in general) the highs are a bit more highlighted, but they are not fatiguing. Nothing I cannot fix from the BTR5's equalizer if it gets annoying though.
Bass is nice and detailed. I managed to understand instruments and separate them better than with the AKGs. In some metal tracks I wished for a bit more bass "slam" though, but I never wished for less, which is more important to me. As a curiosity, I did a low frequency test, starting from 5hz and up. I can clearly start hearing them from 13hz up (according to
this article they start at 10hz).
Regarding the mids, sadly I have too little experience to explain how they sound. All I can say is that the mids are not "in my face", I do not have the sensation that vocals are being shouted to me, but are part of the song itself.
The FD1 reproduces the songs
Utopia (
youtube),
After Time (
youtube),
La Viflaim Colo-n Jos (
youtube),
Summer Dreams (
youtube),
True Story (
youtube),
Voices (
youtube),
Master Code YS63 spot on for what I consider to be really enjoyable for subbass, bass, mids and highs.
A little fearful I decided to try my 2 benchmark songs for highs and "speed" (warning, they are metal, for whom does not like the style):
1.
Borknagar - Up North (
youtube). Vortex's voice sounds so smooth on the FD1. Then, the 3 seconds between min 1.21 and min 1.24 where the double bass and the cymbal "blast in", then from 1.27-1.30, all the instruments are very clear and easily identifiable.
2.
Mgła - Exercises in Futility V (
youtube). Especially starting from min 2:57, where there is so much going on at the same time on the drums, the FD1 has absolutely no issues. I can hear every note nice and clear. If you are curious how the drummer pulls it off,
look here (from min 3:00)
The FD1 has absolutely no issues with these 2 songs. Actually I was pleasantly surprised. So, I approve (also, I can headbang with them on, which is a plus)
Moving on to the fit and comfort, I have to fiddle with them a bit untilI I can feel comfortable and not feel pressure from the tips, but after that I can wear them for multiple hours (the longest I kept them on was 4 hours). Here's are a couple of images with how the FD1 fits in my ear:
As nothing is perfect, I do have one small issue with them though:
Why are they so thick? Why is there is so much open space behind the driver?
I think that Fiio could have made the shell 3-4 mm thinner which could have made them a bit more comfortable as well (especially for winter when I wear beanies).
Couldn't Fiio have tuned the driver in such a way not to be affected by the reduction in internal volume? Or was this a case of "use already available molds/shell" to keep the price down?
In the end, the conclusion is that, for the money I paid for them, the FD1 is awesome and I really like them.