Hi BT, I tried swapping out the balloon tubes from the driver position to the power slot last night. Listened for a few hours that way, and came to the conclusion, that, for my system at least, it sounded a little different . Went back to the balloon tubes in the driver position, and like that much better. In the power slot, the balloon tubes sounded a little more bassy, and a little less clear. That was my impression last night and after swapping them back this morning, confirmed, at least in my system, it was better as drivers. The balloon tubes seem to have a little more bass and that is emphasized in the power slot. If you have not tried to swap the tubes, you should give it a try and see what it sounds like.
Hey cf...this idea of swapping tubes around to 'fine tune' the sound from our tube amps is one I'm sure more folks could benefit from...and not just 'front to back' lol!
I first discovered that it was in fact possible - against all accepted wisdom - to 'mix and match' tubes even strictly from different families so that the 'whole is better than the sum of the parts', way back in Elise days...ie. the FDD20 with the ECC31
, and which worked for most folks (the ECC31 being rather heavy in the bass department!!).
Anyway, fast forward to today, and although within the same family - which is much more likely to succeed, of course - my hunch that altering the mix by substituting one or more Dario EL38s for the Philips 'balloon' version might achieve what I was looking for is turning out more successful than anticipated. And this is with just
one Philips as substitute in the power role! Even after just several hours in my testing adapter, that 'edginess' I mentioned previously has gone...and without any sacrifice elsewhere
whatsoever...unlike trying to achieve the same thing via non-tube electronic filtering (via the Hugo2). And which has confirmed once and for all (for me anyway!) the superiority of such fine tuning via
tubes lol!
...and hence my wish that more folks would experiment with altering their final sound output to suit using this method...especially with intimate knowledge of a particular tube's characteristics, and its shortcomings (no single tube on this planet can really tick
all the boxes 100%!!).
And, of course, trial and error will also be needed...results may not always be as expected/hoped for! Witness your own findings re. the 'balloon' tubes as powers, compared to drivers. In your case, results follow what one would expect, ie. their extra bass being
over-delivered as powers. And yet in my own, with the brighter Darios as drivers, the single balloon in power duties shows no sign whatsoever of being OTT in the bass...just proving that driver/power interaction will differ according to mix of particular tubes. But experimentation is well worth the effort, even if only for interest's sake!!
...so don't be afraid of giving it a try folks...CHEERS!
ps. Swapping front to back in our amps is only really successful with the EL family of pentodes (triode-strapped)...and their abilities in this area - as well as their other attributes - are quite remarkable, in fact!