RedSky0
1000+ Head-Fier
- Joined
- Jan 8, 2008
- Posts
- 1,006
- Likes
- 19
Just got them, listening through rockboxed iPod 5.5G -> Mini^3 (5 Gain).
I hear everything people say they liked about them and none of the downsides.
Incredible detail, drumming is taut and accurate, bass lines in metal are easily heard distinctly. Listening to say string or flamenco passages they again sound amazingly crisp. Both bass and treble extension is great.
As for the supposed downsides. Yes bass with no EQ is not weighty, but adjusting the 20-40Hz frequencies on my rockboxed iPod 5.5G up and the problem is completely remedied making it punchy but not remotely boomy. I can imagine someone expecting delayed bass with more dominance over the sound spectrum not liking it as much, but that would not be me. Don't hear any sibilance and it sounds maybe marginally bright. In fact it definitely fares better here than the iM716s which were somewhat piercing in the higher frequencies and had to be EQed down, something that doesn't need to be done with the ER4Ps.
About the only downside is the soundstage is of course limited given it being an IEM, although from memory it's somewhat wider than the iM716s.
I would do a closer comparison to the iM716 in case anyone is interested (doubtful as they're out of production afaik), but I managed to tear the the cable clean out of the plug just a couple of days before I got them, although I might reterminate it sometime for an A/B comparison ...
Anyway, supremely happy with the definite keeper
I hear everything people say they liked about them and none of the downsides.
Incredible detail, drumming is taut and accurate, bass lines in metal are easily heard distinctly. Listening to say string or flamenco passages they again sound amazingly crisp. Both bass and treble extension is great.
As for the supposed downsides. Yes bass with no EQ is not weighty, but adjusting the 20-40Hz frequencies on my rockboxed iPod 5.5G up and the problem is completely remedied making it punchy but not remotely boomy. I can imagine someone expecting delayed bass with more dominance over the sound spectrum not liking it as much, but that would not be me. Don't hear any sibilance and it sounds maybe marginally bright. In fact it definitely fares better here than the iM716s which were somewhat piercing in the higher frequencies and had to be EQed down, something that doesn't need to be done with the ER4Ps.
About the only downside is the soundstage is of course limited given it being an IEM, although from memory it's somewhat wider than the iM716s.
I would do a closer comparison to the iM716 in case anyone is interested (doubtful as they're out of production afaik), but I managed to tear the the cable clean out of the plug just a couple of days before I got them, although I might reterminate it sometime for an A/B comparison ...
Anyway, supremely happy with the definite keeper