pbirkett
Headphoneus Supremus
- Joined
- Jun 12, 2002
- Posts
- 3,239
- Likes
- 55
One thing I have learned over the last 3 years that I have been involved in hifi as a hobby, I have noticed that this subject, almost more than anything else is full of crap to put it bluntly.
I think most of you know what I mean by now, but I shall give some examples. In a review of a Denon DCD-835 CD player, magazine A claimed it to be a very lively, bouncy, full bodied player. The other magazine, B, claimed that it was very laid back, warm and lacking punch. Now, either a CD player sounds lively or it doesnt??? Surely the same model cannot be lively and laid back at the same time. Yet according to two different magazines, they are completely different players.
Another review, this time of a Rotel amp claims that it is a lively, clean, dynamic and punchy amp (which I know from experience to be true), and another magazine said it is overly smooth, warm, laid back, unengaging (definitely NOT true, its about as far away from the truth as its possible to get). These are identical amps.
Now, forums are just as bad I find. The main thing that sticks out for me is generalisations which tend not to be based on any real experience. I love being told that my soundcard, amp or cans exhibit faults which are plainly not there.
What is the point to this thread? Trust nobody but yourself, and trust only your own ears. Peoples opinions are in many cases, always going to be clouded by bias, exagerration or just plain lies. Unfortunately, with headphone hifi, this is going to lead to many mistakes; I wish it was easier to audition headphone kit... but I wish even more that people would not talk crap!!
Rant over!
I think most of you know what I mean by now, but I shall give some examples. In a review of a Denon DCD-835 CD player, magazine A claimed it to be a very lively, bouncy, full bodied player. The other magazine, B, claimed that it was very laid back, warm and lacking punch. Now, either a CD player sounds lively or it doesnt??? Surely the same model cannot be lively and laid back at the same time. Yet according to two different magazines, they are completely different players.
Another review, this time of a Rotel amp claims that it is a lively, clean, dynamic and punchy amp (which I know from experience to be true), and another magazine said it is overly smooth, warm, laid back, unengaging (definitely NOT true, its about as far away from the truth as its possible to get). These are identical amps.
Now, forums are just as bad I find. The main thing that sticks out for me is generalisations which tend not to be based on any real experience. I love being told that my soundcard, amp or cans exhibit faults which are plainly not there.
What is the point to this thread? Trust nobody but yourself, and trust only your own ears. Peoples opinions are in many cases, always going to be clouded by bias, exagerration or just plain lies. Unfortunately, with headphone hifi, this is going to lead to many mistakes; I wish it was easier to audition headphone kit... but I wish even more that people would not talk crap!!
Rant over!