Quote:
The T5p is all about balancing headphone listening objectives.
Very well said. Other ways to put it:
- The art of compromise
- The art of the possible (i.e. the art of balancing the possible)
This is actually more generally true, and many people seems to forget this. For example a headphone may have the most super duper superior sound, but it doesn't matter if it is impossible to use because of discomfort. I can't use many on ear headphones because of discomfort leading to actual pain after a while.
Another issue is isolation and/or leakage which is very important for many use scenarios whether it is to avoid disturbing others or actually lowering the background noise floor enough to be able to hear the music without listening at loudness levels above ones comfort zone.
A third issue is the amplification needs of a headphone. Some prefer to travel light, or they may not want to invest to much since they only seldom use their headphone outside home, but still like to have the possibility to use it on a trip, for example spending an evening alone in a hotel room on a business trip. Bringing a lot of equipment through airport security check points is both a hassle and a risk.
An example of a "compromise" that suits me fine: I bought an Apple iPod classic mainly for use during long distance train trips (6-7 hours) which I do a few times a year. This was before I really got into headphones, and I read that the Koss Porta Pro was good for portable music, and I see them around town etc. on a daily basis. Now that was a bummer. At my loudness levels I could barely here the music and soon gave up during my first trip. I needed isolation to vastly lower the noise floor. According to many sources closed, well isolating headphones give you good isolation, good sound and value for money. I bought the Sennheiser HD 380 Pro after reading about its qualities including isolation and iPod compatibility. I wasn't exactly floored by neither sound nor isolation. I wanted a simple, compact system, and hence didn't want a separate amplifier.
John Grandberg later listed several good arguments for a choice like mine. Noise cancelling sounded like a good idea, but when you start reading about that, IEMs get frequently mentioned. I generally prefer around ear ear protectors over ear plugs, have lived well with around ear ear protectors since my child hood driving lawn mowers, tractors and more. I also like over ear headphones. This time I was thorough and found information about pros and cons of IEMs which led me to believe I wouldn't be happy with them for my use scenarios. I read up on noise cancelling around ear headphones and found out that Bose QuietComfort 15 was a good candidate. I tried it, got a decent offer and bought it. It works very well for my portable use (scenarios), including an occasional evening alone in a hotel room or other quiet place. Do I have better sound at home? Yes indeed, but the better sound quality of those solutions would be drowned out by the background noise anyway, at least at my loudness levels. It's all about horses for causes within ones budget.
Positive Feedback ISSUE 53 january/february 2011 "
The Headphone/Headphone Amp Roundup: A Humorous Pavin (*)" by Andy Schaub is interesting and covers several systems/combos meant for diferent scenarios and needs.