Final Impressions
Most likely my last impressions on this CDP.
I've been spending a lot more listening than my impressions posts here imply - last weekend, almost every day this week late into the night - because I've been wanting to find out if this is the CDP for me or not, and I am very close to my final rig too, so this has been giving me a lot of insight.
First I have to say, this CDP is amazing! Truly and downright amazing. The areas in which it eclipses the Arcam FMJ CD33 are sheer prowess. The more I've listened to the Ayre and Arcam CDPs, the more I find that they just come from different worlds - both offer some truly excellent sound, just in different ways, and neither is really 100% better than the other. The Ayre has shortcomings in areas that the Arcam doesn't, and likewise the Arcam has shortcomings in areas the Ayre doesn't.
The Ayre is so deeply out-of-this-world musically involving with a hugely fluid sound that just captures your attention. As I've said before it has a kind of "American" sound compared to the "British" sound of the Arcam - assertive, bold, and full of rich tonal colors. My re-cabled K701 and AD2000 show what this machine's bass is made of - truly deep and powerful, it sounds like it's stirring a huge vat of oil or something.
Almost borderline thick maybe, but not outright thick, just a lot of presence and power, the kind that exudes confidence.
And the mid-range - oh, the mid-range. First, the imaging is just spot-on
direct more than anything. It's not a laidback spacious/ambient type image, but more in-your-face and forward. I don't think depth is one of the Ayre's strong suits. That said, the mid-range is also bold, with a very strong push towards body and fullness. When you hear an instrument or vocals, you also feel the power inside, the aching, the soul. It is a little too controlled in the dynamics aspect though - volume shifts are quite smoothed over, as the machine has the kind of sound of showing you the gradation between louder and softer, instead of just jumping between them, like my Arcam does. Trying to fill in the volume gaps, so to speak. I don't perceive this as a good thing - loud and soft should startle you, you shouldn't expect them. The Ayre kinda makes you expect an oncoming loud or soft part.
Treble is very good too - controlled, extended, and allows for very fine resolution. However there's nothing particularly special about it - this is pedestrian treble response IMO. Compared to the Arcam, it could be a bit better - clearer and faster, with even more resolution around the edges of notes, and it seems a bit uneven compared to the Arcam which sounds completely flat. Extremely fast & high sounds are incompletely rendered on it, pretty obvious on the AD2000. I think there's a problem with its attack as well.
Overall, I remain impressed by the Ayre - the musical picture it paints is awe-inspiring, and the sound it creates is so much more vivid. It can show you all the layers in music without them sounding separated, to create a superbly-integrated musical whole front to back, left to right. Backup groups of singers, for example, sound like another part of the track rather than together with the main vocalist, as might happen on lesser CDPs. (Another area in which the Arcam isn't as accomplished.)
But just because it impresses me doesn't mean I love this sound, and comparing it to the Arcam, I prefer more qualities about the Arcam than I do about the Ayre. Where the Ayre integrates everything into a solid image, the Arcam separates everything into individual components - and that's something I prefer more. I prefer that separated sound, I
like to hear everything going on in a track. I've found I don't want the CDP to decide for me what it's going to cast to the side and place less importance on - I want a sound that gives as much equal attention to the individual layers as possible, and the Arcam does that. Granted the Arcam's main deficiency is that it's not very musically involving, and it does sound bass-light next to the Ayre, but it just has more of what I like.
So the quest begins for the next balanced CDP that hopefully has all of what I like...
And on a final note, I have to add that both of these CDPs are amazingly responsive to the effect of an aftermarket power cord! Comparing generic 18 AWG to the Signal Cable Silver Res Reference is such a noticeable difference that I couldn't live with either CDP without the Signal Cable power cord! There's just so much more information with the Signal Cable, truly astounding - more soundstage, a myriad of improvements in articulation and speed, deeper bass, etc. Listening to either CDP without it has become truly depressing!
Oh and on a separate note, the Black Cube Linear is an amazing amp too!!! This unknown amp deserves more credit, it scales effortlessly and its energetic drive is the best I've heard. Some sonic flaws with it compared to my memory of the HeadAmp GS-1 (and I miss the GS-1's transparency as well), but nothing major.