I'm starting a series of comparisons between my current headphones vs the Avantone Planar, using the following setup: Gamma2 DAC -> Topping A90 -> Headphones. I listen mainly to Metal and Progressive Rock, and I usually test using High-Res (if available) music from groups such as Rush, Porcupine Tree, Reverend Bizarre, Steven Wilson, Metallica, etc. I will be using a +/- format, where + is an are where the Avantone does better.
So, let's start against the Ollo S4x, since it is going back soon.
Avantone planar vs Ollo S4x
- SUB-BASS: the first thing that strikes is the S4X has better bass extension. Bass is still present in the Avantone, and well defined, but the sub-bass extension, and avoiding the bass hump so many bassy headphones have, are the main claim to fame of the S4X.
- WARMTH and MUSICALITY: in comparison to the S4X, the Avantone Planar does sound colder, more analytical, more distant, especially for vocals.
- WEIGHT: The Planar is definitely the heavier headphone in this comparison.
- DYNAMICS: You can really hear the drums thumping with the S4X. The Planar can give you some pressure as well, but not as strong.
- LOW VOLUME: The S4X seems to handle lower volume better.
- BUILD QUALITY: This is a short term impression, since I've had both for less than a month, but the Planar creaks and some metal parts rub against each other. The S4X looks well-built and more durable.
+ SOUNDSTAGE: The Planar sounds open, the S4X sounds closed (sound doesn't change when I put my hands on the back of the drivers). This is really a night and day difference between the two. I am able to pinpoint the direction where a sound is coming from with the Planar, and that's not really the case for the S4X.
+ INSTRUMENT SEPARATION and DETAIL RETRIEVAL: I can definitely hear more details with the Planar, especially if they are lower in the mix and in complex part. The S4X is quite competent, easily beating my old HD600, but it cannot handle the complex styles I like as well as the Planar. On STEVEN WILSON - Luminol, I can always hear every instrument on the Planar if I am listening critically, but they become mashed together in certain passages on the S4X.
+ TREBLE: Sounds better on the Planar, yet stay very natural. The S4X's treble is clean, but can be buried under the rest of the frequency range.
+COMFORT: The Planar is definitely the more comfortable here for me: oval earpads vs small, round earpads that are smaller than my ears. It's the main reason I don't intend to keep the Ollo S4X.
CONCLUSION: The Avantone Planar for me is the more technically competent headphone of the two. Both are very good for critical listening, but the Planar has the S4X beaten when it comes to complex, fast music with layers and for good soundstage/air. Go for the S4X if you want strong bass and sub-bass without exaggeration, strong thumping from the drums, if you like a close, intimate sound for more emotional/personal/slower music styles, and if you have ears on the small side.