So I got around to comparing the
Stock Tips,
Comply Isolation tips,
fake Sony Hybrids, and
Spinfit Tips.
Comply Isolation
These tips are great at what they're made for - isolation. If you're in a noisy area, these are a really good choice. Out of all 3 tips I tested, they
blocked out the most noise. Furthermore, they lend themselves to the
best bass of the three. If you manage to cut the excess off, and insert them properly. they will often be
decent fit but I found them to be
the least comfortable. The tip would keep on slipping out of my left ear as it was constantly trying to expand, which caused discomfort. Sound was clear and detailed. My right ear was perfect.
Fake Sony Hybrids
These were
the most comfortable, and had the
best fit (they felt nice and soft and never slipped out, even during movement and exercise), but had
the worst sound. High mids felt pretty hot and uneven in regards to frequency and I got pretty confused when listening to vocals with these, as it felt like certain frequencies were muffled or recessed.
Bass was terrible and virtually nonexistent, even with a deep fit. Furthermore, isolation was virtually nonexistent. All in all, I wouldn't recommend these tips - they left me confused and wanting for more.
Spinfit Tips
Probably
my favorite out of the three. It takes some practice get
a good fit, but they are
extremely comfortable, and provide
great sound. Isolation was much better than the Fake Sony Hybrids. Bass was better than stock, but not as good as Comply, and overall felt more detailed. They also look pretty nice (but can be dust/particle magnets). I'll talk more about the sound
Stock Tips
These were my third favorite, behind Comply and Spinfit. Their isolation falls somewhere in between the fake Sony Hybrids and Spinfits, you can still feel
some bass from them, and they are comfortable enough to not notice. However, they suck for long term use - they tend to fold in on themselves and just don't hold up well with time, becoming less comfortable and more of a nuisance.
Spinfits tips.
So, to rank them:
Isolation
Comply: 4
Spinfits: 3
Stock: 2
Fake SH: 1
Comfort
Spinfits: 4
Fake SH: 3
Stock: 2
Comply: 2
Fit
Spinfits: 4
Fake SH: 3.5ish
Comply: 3
Stock: 2
Bass
Comply: 4
Spinfit: 3
Stock: 2
Fake SH: 1
Overall Sound
Spinfits: 4
Comply: 3
Stock: 2
Fake SH: 1
I've heard great things about the JVC Spiral Dots, so you might want to check those out.