Have made a ranking of phones according to current day
best price (in EUR) /
Provocative Ear (Aproear.co.uk)
rating RATIO. It is interesting that all phones have some different components.
LEADERS (>1):
- Einsear T2 (1; 9) - balanced, tonally nearly neutral, emphasis on bass. Warmer than KR25D and UF MKII. Good for vocals. 10 mm DD.
- boarseman KR25D (1; 9) - V-shaped, delicate, rather neutral. More airy than T2. Detailed. 9,2 mm DD.
FOLLOWERS:
- Swing ie800 (0,9; 10,5) - good V-shaped. For complex music. Not as good as CI880. Large sound stage, good sub bass, better for voices than ZS5; 7 mm DD - similar but bigger than Urbanfun MKII FQ graph peeks.
- Seahf AWK-009 (0,75; 13) - analytical. Slightly forward mids and sharp crisp treble. Track dependent, for small sound volume. Exceptional clarity, good for vocals, string instruments, small bands and rock. Big, just a bit smaller stage than ZS5. 7 mm (?) DD - ie800 like but with extreme high FQ peeks and much less bass.
- KZ ZS5 (0,75; 13) - U shaped + mid centric, direct sound, "live" experience. Large sound stage. For complex music. Less good for vocals. Needs foam tips. Not as good as CI880. 10 mm + 6,4 mm DD + 2x BA. Some FQ response graph similarities with KR25D, which is more neutral.
- E-MI CI880 (0,7; 14) - balanced, strong treble. Considerable accuracy and overall resolution. Most detailed but bright. Excellent mids, no sibilance. Less strong sub bass. Smaller stage that ZS5 but more clear. 7,8 mm DD + BA - have not found FQ response graph online.
- Urbanfun MK2 (0,7; 13) - balanced, midrangeophile. Very detailed but still musical. More neutral than CI880. Excellent vocals. Less clarity, weaker sound stage that other phones in this list. 8 mm DD. - less strong, but more exact bass than Einsear T2.
ONLY cheaper than 15 eur phones which have Aproear rating better than 9 are included. I hope this ranking has no huge flaws and may be useful for new comers. Is something missing?
Some phenomenal
KZ's with rating 9 or less - rather
NEUTRAL:
- EDR2 (2,5; 3,4 eur) - 7 mm DD. V-shaped. Gets better after removing foam from the nozzles (see RBW mod). MOST VALUE. Similar to Urbanfun (original, non MK2) FQ graph but sharper peaks and EDR2 lacks 10Khz peak.
- ZSE (1,9; 4,75) - 8 + 6,8 mm DD - V-shaped, unique experience: dual DD (without BA) + open back design. Nothing is overemphasized, fun and engaging sound. Good bass. Less airy than EDR2. Mids less dark and highs more present and energetic than ZS3 or ATR. Treble could be sharper. Better if you are using EQ / amp, making adjustments - tips rolling, changing insert depth. Recommended for LQ records - Lo-fi hero. KR25D like, more neutral.
- ED9 (1,1; 8) - 6,8 mm DD. Best balanced KZ. Lower resolution, but natural sounding: weaker bass and better mids than AWK-009, less clarity, worse sound stage. Natural drums, female voices, good for jazz. Has nozzle for bassheads. AWK-009 like FQ response curve peaks, but more smooth, neutral.
Strong
BASS:
- ES3 (1,1; 8,4) 10 mm DD + BA. Good clarity, best isolation, works well with Bluetooth sound module. Better if you are using EQ.
To me there are three
questions:
1. does
AWK-009 is the same as
AWK-I009?
2. do I need
Urbanfun MK2 if already have
Einsear T2 and
Swing ie800? Both
T2 and
ie800 have a better cable quality and comfort. Could
Urbanfun MKII be called as
less versatile for different styles of music than
T2? ie800?
3. does
KZ ZS6 (not in a list above, have not listened yet) is a better option for electronic music option than:
bass heavy simple headphones like QKZ DM300, Fonge T01 or Moreblue DM8 +
KZ ZS5 (I know that it might be both - v1 or v2; does not have still but tried and liked).
Why would you favor
ZS6 over
ZS5 + bass heavy headphones? Personally I do not have any phones with a strong bass, but have ordered
ZS6 already. I am inclined to do a
Slater mod for ZS5/ZS6, so I think using cheaper
ZS5 could make more sense. Could
ZS6 / Einsear T2 just be fully enough?
I don't listen to electronic music very often. I do not have almost any experience with IEM phones and want to pick a set of good ones.