Anyone use a Thorens 'table?
Oct 15, 2006 at 3:04 AM Thread Starter Post #1 of 11

Nick 214

Headphoneus Supremus
Joined
Sep 16, 2006
Posts
1,615
Likes
62
Location
Nick 214
Hello all:

I have a chance to get a Thorens TD 280 MKII (1991 vintage) from a local guy for around $110.00 should I do it? I hear it was $330.00 back in '91 so should I ask for a lower price, it has a new belt, And I'd mod the outputs and power input to my satisfaction
600smile.gif
. I THINK it has an older Grado cart on it, I can't tell, but I'll most likely still use My Ortofon S OM10.

Thanks for any help!
 
Oct 19, 2006 at 8:27 PM Post #4 of 11
Todd,

On the subject of Thorens, I've got a TD160 MKI that I'm looking for a new cart for. What would you recommend for the budget minded of us? I've got a Consonance PM-1 phono stage that I'm rehabing so I need a MM cart.

Thanks,

Nate

medium.jpg
 
Oct 25, 2006 at 3:33 PM Post #5 of 11
Ortofon OM-20 works for me
 
Oct 25, 2006 at 6:24 PM Post #6 of 11
Hi Nate,

The Grado and Shure cartridges are also very good and won't break the bank. The Grado Red or the Shure m97xE would be a good place to start.

Todd
 
Oct 30, 2006 at 10:01 PM Post #7 of 11
Quote:

Originally Posted by Todd
Hi Nik 214,

If the Thorens is in good shape then it is a good deal.

Todd



Sorry, but I wouldn't really consider that as a good deal. The 280II by no means is a bad table (the stock Stanton cart was rather horrible, though), but the better Thorenses (146/147/160/318/320 to name a few...) are really a good bit better, but usually not that much more expensive used. Another good alternative in the price range can be a used Dual - especially most of the 7xx and 6xx models, some of the 5xx models (and some of the 12xx changers, but I'm not so familiar with these...). Otherwise I'd recommend to try whether you can haggle a bit - for US$ 80 the 280II would be a good buy.

Gretings from Munich!

Manfred / lini
 
Oct 31, 2006 at 2:53 AM Post #8 of 11
Hi Lini,

No offense taken but it is my position that any turntable in good shape regardless of the cartridge that can be had for $110 is a good deal. There are better turntables of course but to get into vinyl for $110 and maybe another 50-100 bucks for a new cartridge is reasonable to me.

You ought to see the current Thorens TD190 that is $550... I have a hard time thinking it is better...

Todd
 
Oct 31, 2006 at 3:25 AM Post #9 of 11
I ended up buying it. I've got a revamping plan in the works, with a total re-wire, damping,new base and mat and belt, for about $65.00. I ended up getting, I think, a Grado Gold (see other thread). My current table is much nicer, but it's a direct drive modded for hi-fi use (Numark). I'll get some pics up whenever the belt shows up. ( Todd: you really need at Vinyl Junkie smile )
evil_smiley.gif
 
Oct 31, 2006 at 3:08 PM Post #10 of 11
Hi Todd,

no offense meant anyway. I just wanted to mention it, 'cause used TD280s often go for more than they're really worth even over here - I guess, some people think that every Thorens model is automatically high-end or audiophile per se. Or maybe the model number makes 'em believe that 280 must be better than 146/147/160... Anyway, I can see your viewpoint, too - US$ 110 surely aren't extremely overpaid for a TD280II (or something else in that league) in good shape - compared to new turntables that's still a very good deal, no doubt.

Oh, and don't get me even started on the Thorens TD170/190/240. I guess you are aware of these being just Dual OEMs, made by Alfred Fehrenbacher over here? If not, the TD170-1 is a slightly modified CS435-1 - same goes for TD190-1/CS455-1 and TD240/CS455-1M. There's no Thorens version of the CS505-4, instead the TD295IV is based on the ProJect 1.2. Funny situation was that until recently a smart buyer could get one model higher from Dual for just the same price as one model lower from Thorens, e.g. the TD190-1 was as much as the CS455-1M... To amend that, distributor Sintron (who's also behind the new Thorens company, btw) has now also taken over the disribution of Dual and instantly bumped up the prices for the Dual models.
rolleyes.gif
To be honest, there might be more "air" calculated into those new msrps though - in doubt, I'd grant that. Still, the new pricing scheme makes the recently introduced CS455-1M - basically a CS455-1 in a heavier, better looking plinth - less attractive by making it too expensive compared to the more old-fashioned and bland looking, but clearly better CS505-4. The latter could be considered as the last remaining real Dual, btw, and plays about on level, if not a tad better than a good old TD280II - especially in case of bookshelf placement, as the 505-4 is a suspended design...

As to the TD190 costing $ 550 in the US: That's certainly as ridiculous as the CS505-4 for ~ US$ 1000 from the American distributor, iirc. The situation over here isn't as bad despite the recent bumps: Especially HiFi Jäger still offers the 505-4 for moderate 350 Euro, and the CS455-1 Silver for 250 Euro isn't that bad either. (If you mind me mentioning a potential overseas competitor, let me know - I wouldn't think that's a problem for you, though, 'cause I don't think you'd offer the Duals and Thorenses for the inflated US prices, anyway...) Hmm, well, guess I got me started myself...
wink.gif


Greetings from Munich!

Manfred / lini
 
Nov 4, 2006 at 3:56 AM Post #11 of 11
Wasn't the 125 MII the good one? I had one and liked it, as well as a 124.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top