@gregorio , take a chill pill!! I don't think you've understood
@ALRAINBOW , and therefore you're just arguing with yourself. Do you really think berating him will get clearer responses. Or is your goal to simply frustrate him beyond his limit, so he'll just go away?
My interpretation is that he says he hears a difference between hi-res and RBCD with files "as provided by ...?". When he downsamples and then upsamples, the difference disappears, which he thinks makes sense because he thinks
since it has been upsampled it is the same as the hi-res, i.e. not different anymore.
@ALRAINBOW : This is not true!!
@ALRAINBOW If you have 2 files: Album5Track4_2496.wav and Album5Track4_1644.wav and you are certain you hear a difference (e.g. the first one clearly has a lower blacker noise floor), then I can only think of 3 possibilities:
1- You really don't hear a difference, but believe you do. It's a type of illusion, just like an optical illusion.
2- The 2 tracks are supposed to be exactly the same version, other than the first is high res., and the second is RBCD, but(!!) in fact the 2 are different (different masters, or someone did a flawed job of sample rate conversion, or different in some other way).
3- The 2 tracks really are exactly the same except for the sample rate/bit depth, and you have a special gift of amazing hearing. This would be unusual, but very exciting.
So, how to distinguish the 3 cases... (did I miss a possibility?)
A good idea that has already been suggested (and I thought you tried) is use foobar2000 with the foo_ABX plugin. If you need help, check back a few posts, or just ask again.
If you do the ABX, say 16 times, and the difference is not clearly detected anymore, then it seems to be possibility 1 above. Do you see it differently? If so, why?
If you clearly keep hearing the difference with the ABX method, then the question is how to tell the difference between 2 and 3 above. One idea, that would require knowing how and taking the time, would be to analyze the 2 files to see that they really are the same versions.
The simpler method is to do what sander99 wrote above (and others have mentioned in the last few pages): make your own 16/44 version to compare. This will eliminate option 2 (if you do it correctly). Do you know how?
Do you have concerns about then upconverting the 16/44 file to a 24/96 file (sander99 's file B above)?