<£100 canalphones UK (Shure e3c, Etymotic er6i)

Feb 14, 2005 at 5:30 PM Thread Starter Post #1 of 20

krakow

New Head-Fier
Joined
Dec 6, 2004
Posts
11
Likes
0
I'm getting my first pair of 'proper' 'phones (i.e. not free with a portable device).

This is for use with a 4G iPod, without a dedicated headphone amp.

I listen to rock, electronica, avant-garde, modern classical; my particular obsession is post-rock of the mogwai, godspeed, rachels type variety, with a developing taste in the more avant-garde realms of music.

At home my hi-fi system is:
Nad C541i/Terratec DMX 6fire 24/96 --> Nad C370 --> Dynaudio Audience 42
I very much like the way this sounds, though not being very conversant in the language of audiophiles I won't embarress myself by trying to describe the sound.

I tried a few headphones very briefly locally at the weekend, and found the results uninspiring from full headphones, presumably since the iPod was unable to drive them properly unamped (I had to push the volume up beyond 3/4 even in the shop). A very brief try with some Shure e2's was much improved however (with a much better result needing less than 1/2 volume), and settled me on the idea of canalphones as being most suitable.

I was originally considering the full range of canalphones, up to the Etymotic er4p's or westone um2's (both £160+, probably closer to £200 with postage etc).

However I think it makes sense to be a little more conservative money-wise for what will be my first pair of headphones.
Given that the stock apple earbuds are about the best headphones I've used (purely because I've not used anything that didn't come free), I get the impression that almost anything will be a vast step up.

Hence, I'm now considering the Etymotic er6i's and the Shure e3c's. I am unable to try either of these locally, so will have to buy sound unheard, based on advice and reviews.

Both the er6i and the e3c can be purchased from UK sellers on ebay, apparently brand new with full warranties, for £80.

Given this information, are there any further last minute suggestions or pieces of advice?

I've been reading as much information as I can, but the amount is overwhelming and confusing. For this reason please forgive another newbie thread on what may be a very tired subject for you regulars.
 
Feb 14, 2005 at 6:40 PM Post #2 of 20
I'm in exactly the same boat as you. (Well, my prices are in dollars, not pounds, but that's the only difference.)

After a few days of reading, I think the final difference comes down to which kind of sound you prefer. The etys are, I believe, considered to be more flat, while many people find the shures are more "fun." Shures, apparently, leave something to be desired in the treble range but have a very full bass, while the etys can seem more-detailed-than-reality, which can be distracting.

This doesn't really help us out all that much given that we don't know what we're listening to to begin with (1), but I'm waiting on PMs from a couple people who've just gotten shures and so can compare them with Apple's earbuds in terms of balance.

(1) Compared to the earbuds I was using before, Apple's sound a lot less tinny but a lot more... mushy. Everything sounds vaguely like Mazzy Star. But is that because they're blurry or because my other ones were tinny?
 
Feb 15, 2005 at 11:38 AM Post #3 of 20
The £80 price for the Shure E3c's was too good to resist so I ordered a pair last night.
Hopefully they won't take long to arrive and there won't be any hiccups.

Once they do I'll post a layman's reaction to them.

Looking forward to their arrival immensely.
 
Feb 15, 2005 at 2:33 PM Post #4 of 20
I presume that you ordered from ebay.co.uk, I also live in the UK and am seriously considering them as on internet shops they are ~£125 which is a significant difference from £80. However I am a bit cautious about ordering from USA and ebay so could you let me know the seller you got the from and whether they arrived Okay without custom/import taxes with a warrenty, how long they took to ship etc etc. If you have time to do this when taking a break from your new earphones this will be much apprechiated
 
Feb 15, 2005 at 9:36 PM Post #7 of 20
Are there an decent canal phones at £50 or less? I'm looking for some good portable headphones with excellent isolation, it's either Sennheiser SP-25 and they're pushing the size of things. The Sennheiser 290 have excellent isolation but would look a right plonker!

ta
 
Feb 15, 2005 at 10:08 PM Post #8 of 20
You can have the shure e2c for ~£60 from dabs who are a fairly respected company as well as others who do them for £60. If this is too much then sony mdr-ex71 are £26 from amazon, despite people thinking they are bad quality I find them very comfortable which is why im on my second pari now in 2months (bad reliability). Other than that all I can think of is the koss the plug for £16 from http://www.advancedmp3players.co.uk/...products_id=10

but these are suppose to be terrible. Hope this helped.
 
Feb 16, 2005 at 11:55 AM Post #9 of 20
Well my Shure E3c's arrived bright and early this morning.
Ordered at midnight on Monday and they arrived before 9am on Wednesday.
Royal Mail recorded delivery.
Brand new sealed packaging.
All for £80.
You can't argue with that.

:-D

I think the same seller on ebay has the E2's for <£50.

Obviously I thoroughly recommend them, no problems here whatsoever.

http://stores.ebay.co.uk/mp3sound

Get to it UK folks. Yay! Good prices, uk shipper (so no customs or VAT worries). Fast, and they answer email as well.
 
Feb 16, 2005 at 12:33 PM Post #10 of 20
Does he sell the grey e3's? Don't want to look a iplod owner with the white shures!
biggrin.gif
 
Feb 16, 2005 at 12:39 PM Post #11 of 20
Not from what Ive seen, I wanted to know the same thing as the grey ones look a lot better and with fairly high crime in my area I dont want everybody to know that ive got an ipod. But for £40 or so it doesn't really bother me as the cables are black/grey and am very tempted to order some even though I want some full size headphones......
600smile.gif
 
Feb 16, 2005 at 12:42 PM Post #12 of 20
Thanks Krakow, finally a UK seller of the shures that isn't twice the price of the US, thanks for letting me know, as they are brand new do they come with the full warrenty but I dont think that they are an official seller, does this affect the warrenty at all? That really was quick delivery, if i ordered now I could get them before half term was over..........even more tempting.


EDIT:
PS sorry for the double post, didn't read the thread fully.
 
Feb 16, 2005 at 2:20 PM Post #13 of 20
I've just bought a pair of e2c's to replace some broken Sony MDR-EX71s and I now thoroughly recommend them. Initially I was a little underwhelmed as the sound is less bass-heavy than the Sony's, plus it takes a couple of days to get used to wearing them. However now I can wear them for hours at a time in comfort and the sound isolation is excellent, particularly noticable on the tube.

The other thing that's notable is the build quality, after the Sony's these and built like tanks, and as a result I'm confident that I'll get a bit more than 69 months service out of them.

If you can afford them, the e3cs are supposed to be better and more comfortable as they have the ultra-flex sleeves like the Sonys. I wouldn't go for a 'flatter' sound if using the 'phones with a portable so I'm glad I got these instead of the Etymotics.

Simon
 
Feb 16, 2005 at 6:14 PM Post #14 of 20
As far as I know the 2 year warranty is intact.

This is what I emailed them about and they replied to say that yes they come with the 2 year warranty.

They were brand new sealed when they arrived and there's a little warranty card inside the box so it looks reasonable to me.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top