Battle of Basshead Midfi: Fatfreq Scarlett Mini vs Maestro Mini vs Symphonium Titan
Big thanks to
@Damz87 for organising Fatfreq Scarlett Mini tour and
@tfaduh for loaning his personal Fatfreq Maestro Mini as part of the same tour. Symphonium Titan is my personal iem.
Scarlett has the upgraded cable, Maestro Mini has 3rd party cable from XinHS (Aliexpress) and Titan uses stock cable.
Fatfreq Scarlett Mini
To say Scarlett is a bassy IEM is a gross understatement. It’s simply a bass monster. I’m not sure why it is called Scarlett “Mini”; it definitely does not refer to the bass. The tuning is L-shaped, with the deepest and most amount of bass among all IEMs that I have tried and you can buy. Scarlett is capable of slamming bass very deep, weighty, and rumbling with natural decay. Despite its quantity, the bass is well controlled with no distortion I could notice, not bloated, and has very good texture. Unfortunately, that’s all Scarlett delivers.
The mids are recessed and hollow, with vocals feeling quite detached from the music. The female vocals simply sound unnatural. The treble also suffers from roll-off, with not enough sparkle. Indeed, Scarlett is a dark IEM that reminds me of my old Audeze LCD-X. In terms of space, the music sounds as if it comes from a far distance and from one point. This makes imaging very compressed and inaccurate.
Fatfreq Maestro Mini
Maestro Mini is a more balanced IEM, although it would still be categorized as a bassy IEM. The tuning is W-shaped and quite energetic. It has deep subbass and a full midbass punch, although to a lesser degree compared to Scarlett. Like Scarlett, the bass has good natural decay, albeit faster. The lower mids are lifted to add volume and warmth to the vocals. The lower treble is capable of adding sparkle to the music. In most tracks, the treble is well controlled with no sibilance, although some people may find it too energetic. Maestro Mini provides a good sense of space in the music. It has a wide soundstage but is relatively flat.
Symphonium Titan
Titan is also more balanced than Scarlett Mini. The tuning is U-shaped. The bass focuses more on subbass instead of midbass. Therefore, despite how deep the bass hits, it feels like it lacks weight. The vocals sound clean but recessed and lean. The treble is quite smooth and non-peaky, with just enough sparkle. Titan has an intimate soundstage where you feel surrounded by music.
Comparison:
Price
- Fatfreq Scarlett Mini: USD 639 (or 798 with upgraded cable)
- Fatfreq Maestro Mini: USD 479 (or 599 with upgraded cable)
- Symphonium Titan: USD 999
As a side note, it is interesting that Fatfreq’s upgraded cable and connector seem to be identical to Titan’s stock cable and connector. See below.
Bass
All three IEMs—Scarlett, Maestro Mini, and Titan—have outstanding bass quality but with different presentations. Scarlett has the deepest, most rumbling subbass, followed by Titan and Maestro Mini. In terms of midbass, Scarlett again has the heaviest and weightiest punch, followed by Maestro and then Titan. These IEMs have natural bass decay, with Scarlett seeming to have the longest decay, followed by Maestro Mini and then Titan.
- Subbass: Scarlett > Titan > Maestro Mini
- Midbass: Scarlett > Maestro Mini > Titan
Midrange
Maestro Mini has enjoyable, thick, warm vocals. It has good lower mids and upper mids, making it great for both male and female vocals. Titan's vocals are more neutral, leaner, drier, and lack richness in comparison. In my opinion, Scarlett's mids are too recessed and unfortunately muffled. It is hard to recommend Scarlett if you care about vocals.
- Midrange: Maestro Mini > Titan >> Scarlett
Treble
Maestro Mini has the most treble energy. The treble can be quite coarse and grainy. In several tracks, it can be peaky and piercing. Luckily, this does not happen often. At the extreme opposite, Scarlett almost has no treble energy. In my opinion, Titan has the best treble among these three. It strikes an excellent balance: it has enough sparkle but still sounds smooth.
- Treble: Titan > Maestro Mini >> Scarlett
Space and Imaging
In terms of soundstage, Titan is the most intimate, followed by Maestro Mini and Scarlett. Titan and Maestro Mini have very good imaging, while Scarlett's imaging is quite poor. With Scarlett, the music seems to come from a very distant singular point, making instrument positioning a mess.
- Imaging: Titan = Maestro >> Scarlett
Detail Retrieval
In terms of technicality, all three IEMs are roughly on a similar level. Titan has slightly better instrument separation, followed by Scarlett and lastly Maestro Mini.
- Detail: Titan > Scarlett > Maestro Mini (difference is minimal)
Conclusion
To sum up, each of the Scarlett Mini, Maestro Mini, and Symphonium Titan have their own appeal. Scarlett Mini is for bassheads who only care about bass and want the deepest and biggest bass among all IEMs in the market—and don’t really care about mids or treble. Maestro Mini is for those who enjoy an energetic IEM with punchy midbass and warm vocals—at the expense of slightly more elevated treble. Titan would be suitable for those who love rumbling subbass, a more neutral sound, and smoother treble—at the expense of a lack of vocal warmth.