Thanks for the reply! Unfortunately my S4's are about a year and three weeks old, so it doesn't look like I'll be able to claim them on warranty. Maybe this would be a good opportunity for me to save up and upgrade haha. I appreciate the advice about the super glue! I think I might try that out...

Hey everybody! I'm a first-time poster but long-time lurker here. I have some Klipsch S4's that have some damage. I'll include a picture of what's going on because I'm not confident in my ability to explain it.   Basically, the little rubber part that comes down off of each earbud is...