Quote:
|
Originally Posted by sygyzy
Any idea how this would compete with the PPX3, theoretically? I'll order and review it if it can match or come close.
|
The Eddie Current hd 300 is a design a lot like this. But the hd 300 uses a 6sn7 driver tube vs the 6922's in this amp along with the same 6as7/6080 output tube. The 6sn7 is a much better sounding tube as well as being much more rugged. Earlier in this thread I thought outloud about using a 6cg7 driver tube in the Woo(very close in size) which is another better sounding tube thats again far more rugged and reliable. I have used 6922's in preamps for years and always had trouble with section matcing and reliability. I also know the 6922's I have tried sounded either to hard and bright or to dulled. To get a good 6922 or 6dj8 you have to pay $$$ and they are hard to find. Still my big gripe is that tube sections match poorly and the tube never holds up very well, even the good Amperex(real nos) ones I bought from Upscale Audio. I have not found even the best sounding 6922/6dj8's to be anything special.
Now assuming the hd 300 might be a little better than the Woo because of a better basic tube compliment(I have not heard the Woo), I know I like the normal 6cg7 based ppx3 a little better than the hd 300. So, IMO I dont think the Woo will measure up to the ppx3. I have a special ppx3-6sn7 on order that will also allow me to use the big 6080 output tube x2 on the outputs. This amp will drive k1000's too. I do like the 6as7/6080 output tube. I also think the 6080 is a much better tube than the 6as7's from what I have heard from the hd 300 so far. Nothing is definitive here as I have not heard the Woo. But I dont trust the 6922 tube, so I have my doubts about the sound and using two 6922's looks like twice the trouble.
Remember this is conjecture, but I have owned both the ppx3, had the new ppx3 for extended audition and I own the hd 300. The question asked THEORETICALLY how would this amp would compete with the ppx3. This is an honest answer not an attack on the Woo.