So, I had a pair of CAL!s which just broke. I really enjoyed how comfortable they were, but didn't like how they leaked sound, made a buzzing noise, and had obvious durability issues.
I'd like to get an upgrade/replacement. I have a maximum of $300 to spend, though would like to spend closer to $150-$200 unless the reason was overwhelmingly compelling. I'm looking for mainly comfort, durability, and good sound. Detachable components would be a plus, especially cables. So far the ATH-M50 and Shure SRH840 came to mind. I like listening to rock and j-pop, but will mainly be using them to watch anime. Like the CAL!s, I'm looking for closed, over-the-ear headphones.