I'm sorry that my earlier post was quite frankly hugely opinionated and that kind of kicked off the escalation of opinions. You guys seriously know your stuff, and it's simply just a difference of opinion - basically we should be enjoying those differences as opposed to get all spikey about it
I tend towards the surround camp and always will, but each to their own. Great posts all round.
You seemed like you had a bad day and were ready to just let go