Head-Fi.org › Forums › Equipment Forums › Portable Source Gear › Sony Xperia Z1 Compact
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Sony Xperia Z1 Compact - Page 7

post #91 of 97
Quote:
Originally Posted by heatofamatch View Post
 

Sony has in fact made it very clear what their little "hi-res" decal entails: (source)

 

 

1. Frequency response goes above 40kHz (which is what I mean by "compliant" headphones, e.g. the MDR-1)

2. must pass an internal SQ evaluation (i.e. should audibly bear out the benefit of a source that's not just CD-quality)

 

Sony has always made it very clear that their hi-res == anything above CD-spec, they never promised more.

 

Since you doubted that Sony might have downsampled the output, I'm really just trying to point out that

A. according to Sony's internal standards they would not sell a product with downsampled playback as hi-res,

and that B, there's an interview online that says the headphone jack is putting out more than 20kHz.

 

You can argue all day about whether Sony really managed to pull it off, but I don't see anything outlandish with these claims at all. If you think it's a marketing ploy then I think you should ask yourself whether you should believe in the benefits of ANY hi-def audio spec.

 

But listen, you think what you wanna think, it's not like my pride is invested in hi-res audio one way or another. Even if you think it's all a marketing game, it's you who's the williing participant.

 

... and again, HIGHLY laughable when comparing to how other in the same industry are defining HD these days. Do you actually know what you are talking about with those Sony definitions? Headphone that produce 40kHz serve no purpose on human hearing, which stop around 20kHz or so. I am not even taking about headphone, but the sampling rate of the DAC - even the most mediocre audio DAC these days can sample 44.1kHz and pump out 22kHz without any problem, and how is that make them high-res in anyway? If they were all going by that logic of 'minding their own definition and ignoring the rest of the world', no wonder their smartphone business are being widely criticized for playing catching up and showing weak hand in front of their competition. 

 

Do you know what LG claims for hi-res in their G2? a full spec 24/192. That's the same for Samsung for their Galaxy S3 and HTC for One - and those are not even the latest generation of product like Z3. Do you also know that all three of them essentially have the same DAC inside that actually support 24/192? In fact, Sony actually has a 24/192 capable DAC since the days of Xperia Z (the same DAC is also in Z2 and Z3). They just too lazy to implement the full 24/192 that already built into the hardware since 2 years ago.

 

..and it is not about marketing or not, it is about being honest on the products you sold. If Sony want to define 40kHz as hi-res, then let them post it on every page on every product they claims to be hi-res, so people can be informed on how their version of high-res compared to others - not just in Japanese which most people can't read. I don't care about hi-res myself, as I don't even listen to music on smartphone by much - But paying with words doesn't make for a good company practice in the long run, especially since it is unfair to the less informed customer.


Edited by ClieOS - 9/19/14 at 6:52pm
post #92 of 97
I'd like to read the spec's for the DAC and amp in the Z3-c.
Does anyone know of an English source for these?

I'm not really concerned whether Sony is achieving true Hi-Rez as others define it.
What I'm hoping for is a cell-phone which performs well with Spotify and other non Hi-rez sources, and if it does reasonably well with Hi-rez (even if it's down-sampled or whatever) that'll be enough for me.
Proper 24/192 would be a bonus, but it's absence wouldn't put me off completely.
Do we know for sure that the Z3-compact doesn't provide 24/192?.
The performance of the amp/general implementation matters too.
post #93 of 97

The DAC is Qualcomm WCD9320. It has been the default DAC to use since SnapDragon 800 (including 801) and Qualcomm has yet to update it. As far as I know, there is no independent amp section for any of the Xperia smartphone, same for Galaxy S series and most smartphone in the market (as no one has ever find a headphone amp section in any tear down guide. The only exception is Vivo Xplay series). My guess is that, they either use the build-in driver inside the DAC or adds a simple current output stage to boost current output. Nothing similar to what we will refer as amp section in HF.

post #94 of 97

Thanks for responding ClieOS

Where do you find this info?

 

I ask as I'm thinking of upgrading my cell-phone (from current Moto Razr-i) but only want to do so if there's a decent chance the Z1-c or Z3-c will offer noticeably better sound quality (Razr is tolerable, but not inspiring).

 

 

I'm finding it hard to find out if there's likely to be any improvement in SQ from Moto to Sony, and whether I'm better to either:

 

Stick with the Razr

 

Upgrade to Sony but save some cash by getting a used Z1-c @ 180-200GBP

 

or splash out on the Z3-c @ 350GBP as it may (or may not) sound better than the Z1-c

 

So I'd like to compare any audio performance numbers available for the above phones.

Even if the claimed performance doesn't tell the whole story it would make my decision a bit less of a 'stab in the dark'.

 

I know there's other phones which might sound better, but the size and rugged/waterproofing is important to me.

post #95 of 97
Quote:
Originally Posted by Q Mass View Post
 

Thanks for responding ClieOS

Where do you find this info?

 

 

Hardware info can be found on various teardown guide over the web, it just requires some googling around. But they don't have measurement. I'll suggest you wait for gsmarena.com to post the measurement data to give you some idea.

post #96 of 97

OK, thanks ClieOS

post #97 of 97
I have a samsung galaxy s2. For various reasons I don't use it for listening to music, but my contract is up and I can get another phone, and I wouldn't be upset if it produced great SQ. This question may be off topic, but is there a reliable place (ie website or thread) that can tell me which phones have the best SQ?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Portable Source Gear
Head-Fi.org › Forums › Equipment Forums › Portable Source Gear › Sony Xperia Z1 Compact