Head-Fi.org › Forums › Help and Getting Started › Introductions, Help and Recommendations › HD 598 vs HD 600 (which has more detail)
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

HD 598 vs HD 600 (which has more detail) - Page 6

post #76 of 91
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by FancyDan View Post
 

I would say so personally, but I'm kind of an HD600 fanboy. I think they sound better in every way to my ears, but at the end of the day audio is subjective. I recommend you find a way to try both out in person. That's the only way to really know what you want. 

Theres no places near my area that actually have the HD 600. I only can find the HD 650's and 5xx series. No 600's :(

post #77 of 91

That's too bad. Idk what to tell you, they are kind of hard to find anywhere but online. I just did a lot of research first and the HD600 ended up being exactly what i was looking for

post #78 of 91
Thread Starter 

All I wanna know is the HD 600 is a solid Ugrade haha

Which I kind of already know is so I'm currently saving up for them :)

So thanks for all the help! :)

post #79 of 91
The 598s are $187 on amazon now.....you can't beat that price....I listen to all types of metal on these....from modern metal to black metal.....I love em
Edited by inthearmsofrain - 1/22/14 at 5:18pm
post #80 of 91
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by inthearmsofrain View Post

The 598s are $187 on amazon now.....you can't beat that price....I listen to all types of metal on these....from modern metal to black metal.....I love em

I have them too. Not really my type of headphones for metal and rock.

post #81 of 91
Quote:
Originally Posted by Cobaltius View Post

I have them too. Not really my type of headphones for metal and rock.

I agree there are better, I just like the soundstage on these....bass lacks
post #82 of 91
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by inthearmsofrain View Post


I agree there are better, I just like the soundstage on these....bass lacks

Yeah agreed. Soundstage is quite amazing! I do like the highs on these SOMETIMES. Sometimes it is just to high and alittle fatiguing.

I also find these headphones to be alittle bit to loud in the High-Mids 

post #83 of 91

Seems like consensus has been reached, but just want to chime in that purely for music: HD600 > HD598. No contest. It would get more complicated if other types of media would have to be considered, but since that isn't the case here...

post #84 of 91

I'm wrestling with very similar situation here. I have similar music taste, I got Schiit Modi/Vali stack and I currently own the 598's. :D I've done a lot of pondering and I'll probably go for the 650's in the summer. The 598's are simply too bright for me and I feel they lack some body, even though they are great for acoustic music, movies and video games.

post #85 of 91
Thread Starter 

Which one has a more sharper sound in treble?

I'm guessing the 598's huh?

598's don't seem sharp AT ALL for me.

They are bright but not sharp.

post #86 of 91
Quote:
Originally Posted by FancyDan View Post
 

Having tried both of the headphones in question, I can say with conviction that the HD600 is the way to go, especially if you're into energetic music. The HD600 sounds (to my ears) more clear, more powerful, more detailed, maybe not quite as immediate, but it sounds more life-like. To my ears the HD598 sounds fake, like the energy is being taken away from the original recording. They sound in a weird way more flat than actual flat, which sounds weird but if you get a chance to try them both I promise you'll see what I'm saying. The HD600 are my personal favorite headphones Sennheiser has made for the price (except maybe the HD800, which I've tried many times, but never had the pleasure of owning). For rock music the HD600 are in my mind literally the perfect headphone. I don't know if this has been covered, but if you're getting either of the headphones you mentioned, you're going to need an amp at least, and probably also a DAC. If you're on a budget, the Schiit Audio Magni/Modi combo is killer, as is the Little Dot MKII. 

 

I too have owned both & agree that the 600s have more clarity, detail, and I feel are much more immersive. Sure, the 598s are more comfortable in the sense that they're lighter with less of a clamp, but I still enjoy the seal the 600s provide. I think it makes the music feel more intimate.

When I switched back to the 598s, it felt like the mids were too elevated and the overall sound was more laid back & distant.

 

I've listened to some metal with them, and even after reading they don't do as well with that genre, I was impressed with how well they kept up. Granted, I don't listen to metal typically, but it still sounded enjoyable.

 

A few examples of albums I think sound great through the 600s I heard recently:

Daft Punk's Random Access Memories (So fun, detailed, immersive with great bass representation that forced me to dance)

Lorde's Pure Heroine (Also made me dance & I got lost in the lush vocal harmonies)

Adele's 19 (I couldn't help but be entranced by the vocals & acoustic instruments. Felt quite intimate)

 

I think it's misleading to say that the 600s don't sound good with pop/rock.

 

I listened to both with Audinst HUD mx-1 amp/dac.

post #87 of 91
Quote:
Originally Posted by exterious View Post

 

I think it's misleading to say that the 600s don't sound good with pop/rock.

 

I would agree. I think one of the things that make the HD600 such a killer headphone is that you can honestly make them sound great with pretty much anything. If you want more or less punch out of them, they respond with amazing accuracy to EQing and they're full of energy so I wouldn't say they sound "dead" the way the the 598 can. At the same time, however, they're very clear and can be laid back when they want. They're just awesome!

post #88 of 91
Thread Starter 

HD 598 vs HD 600 in Transient Response?

post #89 of 91
I have never listen to the hd600, but if they are similar enough to the hd650, as people says, there is no contest. I have both the hd650 and the hd598 (and the 558 as well), and the hd650 are in an another league. Also, for my taste, the hd558 sounds better than the hd598: very similar over all, but the hd558 gives more "texture" to the music.
Edited by daniel0407 - 2/22/14 at 5:09am
post #90 of 91
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Cobaltius View Post
 

One weird question lol. This might be extremely stupid but I've been noticing for a long time, but I notice when I listen to most of my music on stereo systems or just regular speakers (Even crappy speakers) I notice the snare drums have a plop, pop, or snap to it while when listening to my music on my computer I just sounds textureless or maybe fat. I have no EQ applied at all. I also notice with the toms that I can hear the sharp pointiness of the drum sticks hitting the tom. However If I turn the volume down alot it starts to sound similar as what I would hear on the speakers with the pop sounds to the snare and what not. Is this just because of the sound signature of my headphones since my HD 598's are "in my face" or what is it?

After listening to the drums more and doing a little more research on what I'm talking about here, let me just narrow it down.

Does the HD 600's drums sound soft/muffled, or does it have a snappy, tighness to the drums and percussion?

New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
Head-Fi.org › Forums › Help and Getting Started › Introductions, Help and Recommendations › HD 598 vs HD 600 (which has more detail)