I auditioned both side by side and the HE-500 won out unless being compared to the most recent LCD-2 and LCD-3 products. Because of the drivers issues in the LCD-2 / LCD-3 products I hesitate to recommend them to anyone. There are a few types out there that for the price sound horrible compared to the "fixed" versions. Hopefully the issues go away completely, but the HE-500 is still an awesome sounding headphone.