Originally Posted by
HaggisMacJedi 
I have both of the Sony Wireless headsets, and they are both VERY good for use with the PS3. I have used my ATH M50's and Turtle Beach X1's with my PS3 as well, and they simply do not compare with the Sonys for use with the PS3. Gaming headsets are very specialized and need to be set up differently than music headphones. The Pulse feature is not intended to "fake" bass tones and make it feel like the bass is deeper than it is. It is not a gimmick. It is intended to give the listener the sensation of what is happening in the game right there in their lap. For instance, in the "shooter" mode, the Pulse headphones emphasize explosions, footsteps, etc with a pulsing of the earcups in addition to the sounds. You FEEL the explosions as well as hear them...just as you would in real life. These are not intended to compete with high end consumer music headphones. They ARE intended to compete with high end gaming headsets, and they do that very well.
As a bonus, they do sound nice with music, especially if used wirelessly with a MacBook Pro, or while using the PS3's "Music Unlimited" service. They do not have the clarity of the ATH M50's in the mid range or highs, but they aren't far off. I think it's a generous bonus that my gaming headphones work as pretty decent music phones. I didn't get them to rock with my iPhone on the commute to work; I got them to blast the enemy in Call of Duty: Black Ops II.
I do think these are improved in every way over the original Sony Wireless PS3 headset except for comfort. The originals are lighter, and the headband is cushier. For what it's worth, I'm keeping my originals instead of selling them.
My bottom line is if you are a PS3 gamer, don't waste your time or money with more expensive (or cheaper) Turtle Beach or Astro headsets because these will out perform them on the PS3. If you are looking at these simply for music, I would recommend the ATH M50's for about the same money.